Ms HUBLI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LIMITED vs RENEW WIND ENERGY KARNATAKA PRIVATE LIMITED

Case NumberRP/1/2025

Date of Filing4 Feb 2025

Case TypeReview Petition

Last Hearing12 Nov 2025

Court⚖️ Karnataka Electricity Regulatory Commision ↗

StateKarnataka

CityBengaluru

Year of Filing2025

Petitioner

MS HUBLI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LIMITEDNot Applicable AGED ABOUT 1 YEARSGENERAL MANAGERHUBLI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LTD.NAVANAGAR
P.B ROAD
HUBBALI580025

Respondent

MS CHAMUNDESHWARI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY CORPORATION LIMITEDNot Applicable AGED ABOUT 1 YEARSGENERAL MANAGERCHAMUNDESHWARI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY CORPORATION LIMITEDCORPORATION OFFICE
NO. 29
VIJAYANAGAR
2ND STAGE
HINKAL
MYSORE560017

MS HUBLI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LIMITEDNot Applicable AGED ABOUT 1 YEARSGENERAL MANAGERHUBLI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LTD.NAVANAGAR and P.B ROAD filed Case No. RP/1/2025 in the Karnataka Electricity Regulatory Commision on 4 Feb 2025 against MS CHAMUNDESHWARI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY CORPORATION LIMITEDNot Applicable AGED ABOUT 1 YEARSGENERAL MANAGERCHAMUNDESHWARI ELECTRICITY SUPPLY CORPORATION LIMITEDCORPORATION OFFICE and NO. 29. The case has undergone 7 hearings over 7 months. The case is currently pending.

12NOV 2025
Common order is pronounced on 12.11.2025. Parties be intimated. Registry is directed to upload the copy of this order on website of KERC. The original order be kept in OP No. 01/2025 and the copy of it be kept in other connected petition.
Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)
Stage: FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS
14OCT 2025
Case called for hearing on maintainability on 14.10.2025. Counsel for petitioner No. 1 to 4 Sri. Shahbaaz Hussain for Precinct Legal present. Counsel Sri. Girik Bhalla on behalf of the Sri. Vishrov Mukerjee present for respondent No. 1. Counsel for petitioner has filed Xerox copy of the statement of objections filed in RP No. 02/2022 and addressed arguments on maintainability. Counsel for the respondent No. 1 addressed arguments on maintainability citing Hon’ble Supreme Court’s Judgement and concluded. Commission heard the counsel for petitioner No. 1 to 4 and respondent No. 1 and reserved the case for orders on maintainability. Further, liberty is given to the parties to file their written submissions if any, before the registry within a week’s time with a copy to each other.
Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)
Stage: FOR HEARING ON MAINTAINABILITY
9SEP 2025
Case called for hearing on limitation & maintainability of Review Petition on 09.09.2025. Counsel for petitioners 1 to 5 Ms. Sindhu G. Koushik present on behalf of Sri. Shahbaaz Husain for Precinct Legal, prays for time to address arguments on limitation & maintainability by senior counsel. Counsel Sri. Sudeesh appeared for R-1 on behalf of Sri. Vishrov Mukerjee for Trilegal. Commission heard the counsels and granted time for petitioners to address arguments on maintainability on the point of limitation. Call on 14.10.2025.
Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)
Stage: FOR HEARING ON MAINTAINABILITY
12AUG 2025
Case called for hearing on 12.08.2025. Counsel for petitioners (R-1 to R-5) Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda for Precinct Legal present, submits that a similar case for hearing on limitation and maintainability is scheduled for hearing on 09.09.2025 and prays to list the present petition also on 09.09.2025. Counsel for R-1 Ms. Nishtha Kumar for Trilegal present and submits that reply of R-1 to the review petition is filed in the registry on 11.08.2025 with a copy to petitioners. Commission heard the counsels, noted their submissions and adjourned the case for hearing on maintainability. Call on 09.09.2025.
Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)
Stage: FOR STATEMENT OF OBJECTIONS
15JUL 2025
Case called for hearing on limitation and maintainability of the petition on 15.07.2025. Counsel for petitioner (R-1 to R-4) Ms. Stephania Pinto for Precinct Legal present. Counsel Ms. Nishtha Kumar appeared for R-1, undertakes to file vakalath and prays time to file statement of objections for R-1. Petitioner counsel further submitted that IA is filed in the registry for transposition of BESCOM as petitioner No.5 and prays to allow the same. Commission heard the counsels, granted time for R-1 to file objections with a copy to petitioners pending hearing on maintainability. Further it is ordered that IA for transposition of R-2 BESCOM as petitioner No.5 is allowed and directed the petitioner advocate to implead the Respondent No.2 as petitioner No.5 and to file necessary amended petition. Call on 12.08.2025.
Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)
Stage: FOR HEARING ON ADMISSION & APPEARANCE OF RESP.(S)
10JUN 2025
Case called for hearing on limitation and maintainability of the petition on 10.06.2025. Counsel for petitioners’ Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda for Precinct Legal present, made submissions and prays time to argue on the point of limitation and maintainability. No representation for R-1 & R-2 despite service of notice. Commission heard petitioners’ counsel and granted time. The registry is directed registry to issue notice to the respondents. Call on 15.07.2025.
Judge: Two Members Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)
Stage: FOR ADMISSION AND APPEARANCE OF RESPONDENT(S)
8APR 2025
Case called for admission of Review Petition on 08.04.2025. Counsel for petitioners 1 to 4 Sri. Shahbaaz Husain for Precinct Legal present, made submissions for Review of the Commission’s Order dated 07.03.2023 in OP No. 17/2019 to the extent of determination of status of captive generator/user and to uphold the demand notices imposing CSS and difference in electricity tax issued by the petitioners and on IA dated 14.02.2025 for condonation of delay in filing the review petition and prays to admit the Review Petition. Commission heard the counsel, noted the submissions, pending admission of the petition, directed the registry to issue notice to the Respondents for hearing on limitation and maintainability of the petition. Call on 10.06.2025.
Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)
Stage: FOR ADMISSION