Ms Devarahipparigi Wind Power Private Limited vs The State of Karnataka

Hearing History (11)

• 21APR 2026
  Case called for hearing on maintainability on 21.04.2026. Counsel for petitioner Sri. M.S. Raghavendra Prasad and counsel for R-2, R-3 & R-5 Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda for Precinct Legal present. Both counsels made their respective submissions on the maintainability. Respondent counsel pray time to file memo on the status of invoices which are accepted and which are rejected along with acknowledgment. Petitioner counsel prays for copy of the same to address arguments on maintainability. Commission having heard the counsels, granted time for Respondents to file memo with a copy to petitioner within a weeks’ time. For hearing on maintainability, call on 02.06.2026.

  Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR HEARING ON MAINTAINABILITY

• 3FEB 2026
  Case called for arguments on 03.02.2026. Counsel for petitioner Sri. M.S. Raghavendra Prasad and counsel for R-2, R-3 & R-5 Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda for Precinct Legal present. Both counsels addressed the arguments on maintainability. The respondent’s’ counsel undertook to furnish information on the status of invoices produced by the petitioner in support of claim, after instructions received from their client on the next date of hearing. Meantime, both counsels have made their submissions to refer the matter to grid controller of India (earlier known as POSOCO) for suitable report on generation loss since, similar cases are also referred to them for determination of generation loss. Further, both counsels pray time to address arguments on the point of limitation and maintainability with relevant records. Commission heard the counsels and granted time. To hear on maintainability, call on 21.04.2026.

  Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR ARGUMENTS

• 13JAN 2026
  Case called for hearing on 13.01.2026. Counsel Sri. Nithish present for petitioner on behalf of Sri. M.S.Raghavendra Prasad, filed rejoinder for R-2 & R-3 along with separate rejoinder for R-5 (KPTCL) with a copy to Respondents. Counsel for Respondents (R-2, R-3 & R-5) Ms. Diksha Pherwani for Precinct Legal present. Both counsels pray for time to address arguments. Commission heard the counsels and granted time. For arguments, call on 03.02.2026.

  Judge: Two Members Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)

  Stage: FOR REJOINDER

• 9DEC 2025
  Case called for hearing on 09.12.2025. Counsel for petitioner Sri Nitish for M.S. Raghavendra Prasad present. Counsel for R2, R3 R4 Sri Sumanth Gowda for Shahbaaz Hussain for Precinct Legal present and filed statement of objections for R5-KPTCL. Counsel for petitioner prays for time to file rejoinder. Commission heard the counsels, granted time to file rejoinder. Call on 13.01.2026.

  Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR OBJECTIONS AND REJOINDER

• 11NOV 2025
  Case called for hearing on 11.11.2025. Counsel Sri. Nithish present for petitioner on behalf of Sri. M.S. Raghavendra Prasad and submits that R-6 (KPTCL) is yet file objections and prays for time to file rejoinder after receipt of the same. Counsel for R-2 to R-4 and R-5 Ms. Diksha Pherwani for Precinct Legal present, prays two weeks’ time to file objections on behalf of R-5 – KPTCL. Commission heard the counsels and granted time to R-5 to file statement of objections within two weeks with a copy to petitioner for filing rejoinder if any. Call on 09.12.2025.

  Judge: Two Members Bench - HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR OBJECTIONS AND REJOINDER

• 16SEP 2025
  Case is called for hearing on 16.09.2025. Counsel Sri. Nitish present for petitioner on behalf of Sri. M.S. Raghavendra Prasad, submits that amendment is carried out in the main petition, amended petition is filed in the registry on 09.09.2025 along with insertion of para 11A and prays to allow the same. Counsel for R-2 and R-3 Ms. Diksha Pherwani for Precinct Legal present and prays two weeks’ time to file objections for R-5 (KPTCL). No representation from R-1 & R-4. Commission heard the counsels, noted their submissions and took the amended petition on record filed by the petitioner with the consent of R-2 and R-3 with respect to insertion of para 11A in the amended petition and granted time for KPTCL-R-5 to file objections with a copy to petitioner for filing rejoinder if any. Call on 11.11.2025.

  Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR APPEARANCE OF RESPONDENT(S) AND OBJECTIONS

• 12AUG 2025
  Case called for arguments on 12.08.2025. Counsel for petitioner Sri. M.S. Raghavendra Prasad present, made submissions on the merits and filed IA to implead KPTCL as Respondent to the present petition in view of filing objections by R-2 and R-3 on maintainability and prays to allow the same. Counsel for R-2 and R-3 Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda for Precinct Legal present and says no objection to allow the interim application to the present petition. R-1 & R-4 not represented. Commission heard both parties, noted their submissions and IA filed by the petitioner is allowed and further directed the petitioner counsel to carry out the amendment in the main petition and to file amended petition with a copy to Respondents for filing objections if any. Call on 16.09.2025.

  Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR ARGUMENTS

• 22JUL 2025
  Case called for hearing on 22.07.2025. Counsel for petitioner Sri. M.S.Raghavendra Prasad present. Counsel for R-2 & R-3 Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda for Precinct Legal present filed statement of objections for R-2 & R-3 with a copy to petitioner. Petitioner counsels prays time to file rejoinder and address arguments. R-1 & R-4 not represented. Commission heard the counsels and granted time. Call on 12.08.2025.

  Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR STATEMENT OF OBJECTIONS

• 24JUN 2025
  Case called for hearing on limitation and maintainability on 24.06.2025. Counsel for petitioner Sri. M.S. Raghavendra Prasad present. Counsel for R-2 & R-3 Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda for Precinct Legal present, submits that since the petitioner has not provided the clear and legible copies of invoices, objections could not be filed on the point of limitation. Hence, prays for a direction to the petitioner advocate to furnish the legible copies. Petitioner counsel undertook to furnish legible copies and to share the same to respondent advocate’s through e-mail ID. R-1 & R-4 not present despite service of notice. Commission heard both the counsels, directed the petitioner advocate to furnish the soft copies of the petition and documents annexed to the Respondents within a weeks’ time and directed the Respondents to file objections within fifteen days thereafter with a copy to the petitioner. Further, directed the petitioner advocate to upload the petition and documents with proper index in the e- filing portal. Call on 22.07.2025.

  Judge: Two Members Bench - HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR APPEARANCE OF RESPONDENT(S) AND OBJECTIONS

• 10JUN 2025
  Case called for hearing on limitation and maintainability of the petition on 10.06.2025. Counsel for petitioner Sri. M.S. Raghavendra Prasad present, made submissions for payment of invoices for deemed energy along with interest on delayed payments. Counsel Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda present, submits that vakalath is filed for R-2, R-3 & R-4 and prays time to file objections on the point of limitation. R-1 & R-5 not present. Commission heard both counsel and granted time to file objections on limitation as prayed by the counsel for R-2 to R-4. Registry is directed to issue notice to R-1 and R-5. Call on 24.06.2025.

  Judge: Two Members Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)

  Stage: FOR HEARING ON ADMISSION & APPEARANCE OF RESP.(S)

• 8APR 2025
  Case called for admission on 08.04.2025. Counsel for petitioner Sri. M.S. Raghavendra Prasad present, made submissions for payment of certain invoices raised by the petitioner towards supply of deemed energy in the back drop of Commission Notification dated 02.02.2016 and in terms of communication letter of MNRE dated 01.08.2019 corresponding with necessary official memorandum and prays to admit the petition. Commission heard the counsel, noted the submissions, pending admission of the petition, directed the registry to issue notice to the Respondents for hearing on limitation and maintainability of the petition. Call on 10.06.2025.

  Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

  Stage: FOR ADMISSION