Meta Pixel
CNR: --
DISPOSED

Ms Greenergy Solar Enterprise Private Limited vs Bangalore Electricity Supply Company Limited

Case NumberOP/19/2024
Date of Filing5 Aug 2024
Case TypeOriginal Petition
Last Hearing28 Oct 2025
StateKarnataka
CityBengaluru
Year of Filing2024

Party Details

Petitioner
  • MS GREENERGY SOLAR ENTERPRISE PRIVATE LIMITED AGED ABOUT 18 YEARSNot ApplicableNOT APPLICABLENO.324
  • 1ST FLOOR
  • GOLDEN POINT NO.4VASANT NAGAR
  • OFF QUEENS ROAD CROSS
  • BENGALURU-560052
Respondent
  • BANGALORE ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LIMITED MANAGING DIRECTORBANGALORE ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LTD.
  • K.R CIRCLE BANGALORE 580 001580001

Case Summary

MS GREENERGY SOLAR ENTERPRISE PRIVATE LIMITED AGED ABOUT 18 YEARSNot ApplicableNOT APPLICABLENO.324 and 1ST FLOOR filed Case No. OP/19/2024 in the Karnataka Electricity Regulatory Commision on 5 Aug 2024 against BANGALORE ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LIMITED MANAGING DIRECTORBANGALORE ELECTRICITY SUPPLY COMPANY LTD. and K.R CIRCLE BANGALORE 580 001580001. The case has undergone 12 hearings over 1 year and 2 months. The case was disposed of on 28 Oct 2025.

Hearing History (12)

  • 28OCT 2025
    Common order is pronounced on 28.10.2025. Parties be intimated. Registry is directed to upload the copy of this order on website of KERC. The original order be kept in OP No. 18/2024 and the copy of it be kept in other connected petition.

    Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS

  • 9SEP 2025
    Case called for hearing on 09.09.2025. Counsel Ms. Nayanashree present for petitioner on behalf of Sri. Shridhar Prabhu for Navayana Law offices. Counsel for R-1 & R-2 Ms. Diksha Pherwani present on behalf of Sri. Shahbaaz Husain for Precinct Legal present. Both counsels reiterated having addressed arguments on their part and prays time to file relevant documents/records. Commission heard the counsels, noted their submissions and granted time by directing both the parties to file their respective documents in support of their claim within a weeks’ time in the registry with a copy to respective parties and reserved the case for orders

    Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR COMPLIANCE AND OBJECTION

  • 5AUG 2025
    Case called for arguments on 05.08.2025. Counsel for petitioner Sri. Shridhar Prabhu for Navayana Law Offices and counsel for R-1 & R-2 Ms. Stephania Pinto for Precinct Legal present. Both counsels made submissions and address arguments on the merits of the case and pray time to file relevant records with a memo. Commission heard the counsels, noted the submissions and arguments of both counsels and granted time to file relevant records/submissions. Call on 09.09.2025.

    Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR ARGUMENTS

  • 15JUL 2025
    Case called for arguments on 15.07.2025. Counsel for petitioner Ms. Sharvari present on behalf of Sri. Shridhar Prabhu for Navayana Law Offices. Counsel for R-1 Sri. Sumanth K. Gowda for Precinct Legal present and filed statement of objections for R-1 with a copy to the petitioner. Both counsels pray time to address arguments. Commission heard counsels and granted time to address arguments. For arguments, call on 05.08.2025.

    Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR ARGUMENTS

  • 1JUL 2025
    Case called for arguments on 01.07.2025. Counsel for petitioner Ms. Vaishnavi present on behalf of Sri. Shridhar Prabhu for Navayana Law Offices and prays for time to address arguments. Counsel for R-2 Ms. Deeksha for Precinct Legal present and prays two weeks’ time for filing statement of objections. Commission heard both the counsels, granted time for R-2 to file objections on or before 15.07.2025 with a copy to petitioner. For arguments, call on 15.07.2025.

    Judge: Single Member Bench - JA(M)

    Stage: FOR ARGUMENTS

  • 3JUN 2025
    Case called for hearing on 03.06.2025. Petitioner counsel Ms. Sharvari for Sri. Sridhar Prabhu present. Counsel for respondent No. 2 Ms. Stephania Pinto for Precinct Legal present and submitted that they have received information from 1st respondent-BESCOM and pray for time to file vakalath. Commission heard both counsel, allowed the application field by the petitioner for re-opening case and permitted the counsel for BESCOM to file vakalath and statement of objections if any in the registry. For arguments, call on 01.07.2025.

    Judge: Two Members Bench - HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR HEARING

  • 15APR 2025
    Case called for hearing on 15.04.2025. Counsel for Petitioner Ms. Vaishnavi present on behalf of Sri. Shridhar Prabhu for Navayana Law Offices. Counsel for Respondents Ms. Stephania Pinto for Precinct Legal present, made submissions that there are certain technical issues in revising the energy bills and prays for time to address the arguments on merits. Commission heard the Respondent counsel and noted that the Commission is in receipt of letter of BESCOM dated 06.11.2024 wherein it is stated that Respondent-BESCOM is in process of settlement of claims of petitioner and requested the petitioner to withdraw the petition pending before the Commission in OP No. 19/2024. Considering the submission of BESCOM official and contents of the letter addressed by the BESCOM to petitioner, case was disposed off on 19.11.2024. But in pursuance of IA dated 11.02.2025 of the petitioner, case is again listed for hearing. Under these circumstances the Respondent counsel prays two weeks’ time to seek instructions from client in this regard and to address arguments on merits. Commission granted time. Call on 03.06.2025.

    Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR HEARING

  • 18MAR 2025
    Case called for hearing on 18.03.2025. Counsel for petitioner Ms. Iswarya present on behalf of Sri. Shirdhar Prabhu for Navayana Law Offices, submits that no settlement is forthcoming for revising the energy bills as per letter dated 11.11.2025 of BESCOM. Hence filed memo for re-opening the case and prays for re-open the case for adjudication. Counsel for Respondent Ms. Stephania Pinto for Precinct Legal present, submits that revising the energy bills is under process by Respondent office and would be finalised within two weeks. Commission heard both the counsels and directed both parties to settle the issue amicably and in the event of any differences in the claims, directed to revert back to commission for further hearing. Call on 15.04.2025.

    Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR HEARING

  • 19NOV 2024
    Case called for hearing on 19.11.2024. Counsel for petitioner Sri. Chiranth for Navayana Law Offices present. Party-in-person Smt. Tarana DGM (Power Purchase) BESCOM present for R-1 and submits that a letter dated 11.11.2024 has been addressed to petitioner company to withdraw the present petition in view of the necessary action taken for settlement of claims for revising the energy bills and crediting the difference energy as banked energy besides arranging payment for unutilized banked energy in terms of Wheeling and Banking Agreement and prays to take the same on record. Counsel Sri. Sumanth Gowda for Precinct Legal present for R-2, undertakes to file vakalath and memo in the registry to the effect that R-2 is not filing statement of objections. Commission heard counsels, noted the submissions of petitioner counsel and the officer of Respondent-BESCOM and directed the petitioner and 1st Respondent-BESCOM to settle the issue amicably between them as mentioned in terms of letter dated 11.11.2024 filed by Respondent-BESCOM. Further, liberty is given to the petitioner to approach the Commission in the event, if any differences in the calculation on the lapsed energy charges between respondent-BESCOM. The petition is disposed off accordingly.

    Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR APPEARANCE OF RESPONDENT(S) AND OBJECTIONS

  • 5NOV 2024
    Case called for hearing on 05.11.2024. Counsel for petitioner Sri. Chirantha for Navayana Law Offices present. Party-in-person Smt. Tarana, DGM (Power Purchase), BESCOM present and submitted that process of calculation is doing in the Corporate office based on the claims made by the petitioner and prays for time to file the same with a copy to the petitioner. No representation from R-2 (KPTCL) despite service of notice. Commission took note of the submissions of party-in-person, granted time to file memo of calculation with a copy to petitioner and directed the registry to issue notice to R-2. Call on 19.11.2024.

    Judge: Single Member Bench - HKJ(L)

    Stage: FOR APPEARANCE OF RESPONDENT(S)

  • 1OCT 2024
    Case called for hearing on admission on 01.10.2024. Counsel for petitioner Sri. Shridhar Prabhu for Navayana Law Offices present, made submissions that respondents have charged the petitioner both under GEOA Rules, 2022 and subsequent GEOA, Regulations, 2023 issued by the Commission, despite Commission’s clarification letter that WBA charges will not be imposed on individual like petitioner. the respondents have raised invoices both under GEOA Rules, 2022 and GEOA Regulations, 2023 which amounts to duplication. The petitioner not covered under GEOA Regulations and prays to admit the petition for refund of certain charges imposed on them for their lapsed energy. Commission heard the counsel, took note of the submissions, admitted the petition and directed the registry to issue notice to the Respondents. Call on 05.11.2024.

    Judge: Two Members Bench - HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR HEARING ON ADMISSION

  • 27AUG 2024
    Case called for admission on 27.08.2024. Counsel Ms. Ishwarya for Navayana Law Offices present for petitioner, made submissions for refund of certain charges imposed by Respondents for certain units of lapsed energy under GEOA Regulations though they are not covered under the same and prays to admit the petition. Commission heard the counsel and sought to know, how the petitioner is affected and entitled for compensation with relevant material evidence. Petitioner counsel prays time to furnish the same. Granted time. For hearing on admission, call on 01.10.2024.

    Judge: Full Bench - PRK(C)+HKJ(L)+JA(M)

    Stage: FOR ADMISSION