MUNAVAR @ MUNNA ABDUL GAFFAR SHAIKH vs STATE OF GUJARAT

1 OMP5PVPG\P **#qZ_Z# S[; NFB, TFZLB !!q_(qZ_Z# S[; GF[\W6L TFZLB !!q_(qZ_Z# S[; O[\;, TFZLB !(q_(qZ_Z# ;DI UF/M JQF" DF; lNJ; vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv DC[ZAFG E~RGF +LHF V[0LXG, ;[;g; HH ;FC[AGL SM8"DF\4 D]SFD o E~RP vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv lS=DLP5ZR]P VZHL G\P **#qZ_Z#P VF\Sv VZHNFZ ov D]GFJZ pO"[ D]gGF VaN], UOOFZ X[B4 ZC[P UW[DFZ4 zL BM0LIFZ DFTFGF D\lNZ 5F;[4 TFP WM/SF4 lHP VDNFJFNP PPPlJ~wWPPPP ;FDFJF/F o v zL ; Z SF Z AFATov lS=DLG, ÝM;LHZ SM0GL S,Dv$#) D]HA HFDLG VZHLP ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo VZHNFZqVFZM5L TZO[ lJPJSL,zL V[DPV[DP5FGJF,FP ;FDFJF/Fq;ZSFZzL TZO[ lJPV[P5LP5LPzL V[GPV[DPlD:+LP ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo voo 9 ZF J oov s!f VF SFDGF VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ CF,GL VZHL E~R XC[Z ;Lv0LJLhG 5M,L; :8[XGGF U]gCF ZHL:80" G\P!!!))__!Z#_!(ZqZ#4 .P5LP SM0GL S,Dv#*)4!!$ D]HAGF U]gCFGF SFD[ lS=P5|MPSM0GL S,Dv$#) D]HA VF\Sv!

GL HFDLG VZHLDF\ H6FJ[, SFZ6M;Z Z[uI],Z HFDLG D[/JJF DF8[ T[DGF 2 OMP5PVPG\P **#qZ_Z# lJPJSL,zL DFZOT[ ZH] SZ[,L K[P sZf VZHL NFB, YTF ;FDFJF/FG[ GM8L; SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P ;FDFJF/F TZO[ lJPV[P5LP5LPzL V[GPV[DPlD:+L CFHZ ZC[,F K[P VZHNFZqVFZM5L TZO[ lJPJSL,zLGL TYF ;FDFJF/F TZO[ lJPV[P5LP5LPzLGL N,L,M ;F\E/LP VZHNFZ TZO[ ZH] YI[, N:TFJ[HL 5]ZFJF4 T5F; SZGFZ VD,NFZG\] ;MU\NGFD] TYF 5M,L; T5F;GF SFU/M J\RF6[ ,LWFP s#f ;NZ SFDGF VZHNFZqVFZM5L TZO[ lJPJSL,zLGL N,L, K[ S[4 VF SFDGF VZHNFZqVFZM5L TN'G lGNM"QF K[ VG[ SC[JFTM SM.

U]gCM SZ[,M GYL T[DH VZHNFZqVFZM5LVM U]gCFGF SFD[ ;LWL ZLT[ S[ VF0STZL ZLT[ ;\0MJFI[,F GYLP VZHNFZqVFZM5LG[ DF+ X\SFGF VFWFZ[ VFZM5L AGFJL V8S SZJFDF\ VFJ[,F K[P VFZM5L lJ~wW SM.

T5F; SZJFGL AFSL ZC[TL GYL4 VZHNFZ ;FD[ 5|YD NX"GLI S[; GYLP VF SFDGF VZHNFZqVFZM5L ;FD[GL 5M,L; T5F; 56 DCNV\X[ 5]6" Y.

UI[,L K[P VF1F[5LT U]gCFGL .g;FOL SFI"JFCL R,FJJFGL ;tTF HI]PD[HLPOPSPzLG[ K[ VG[ DCtTD +6 JQF"GL S[NGL ;HFGL HMUJF.

FGL HMUJF.

K[P JW]DF\ VF SFDGF VZHNFZ GF;L EFUL HFI T[JF .;D GYLP GFPSM8" HFDLG D]ST SZTL JBT[ H[ SM.

56 XZTM OZDFJX[ T[ TDFD XZTMG\] 5F,G SZJF VZHNFZqVFZM5L ZFHL K[P p5ZMST ;\HMUMDF\ IMuI XZTMG[ VFWLG HFDLG p5Z D]ST SZJF VZH U]HFZ[, K[P s$f OlZIFN 51F TZO[ lJPV[P5LP5LPzLGL N,L, K[ S[4 VF SFDGF VZHNFZq VFZM5LVM ;FD[ .P5LPSM0GL S,Dv#*)4!!$ D]HAGF U]gCFGM VF1F[5 K[P VF SFDGF VZHNFZqVFZM5L ;FD[GL 5M,L; T5F; RF,] K[P VZHNFZqVFZM5L ;FD[ 5|YD NX"GLI 5]ZFJM K[P VZHNFZ VDNFJFN lH<,FGF ZC[JF;L K[ VG[ VFZM5LGM 3 OMP5PVPG\P **#qZ_Z# U]GFlCT E]TSF/ K[P HFDLG D]ST SZJFDF\ VFJX[ TM OZLIFNL TYF ;FC[NM ;FY[ h30M SZL ;],[CXF\lTGM E\U SZ[ T[JL XSITF K[P VZHNFZqVFZM5LG[ HFDLG D]ST SZJFDF\ VFJX[ TM GF;L EFUL HJFGL VG[ .g;FOL SFI"JFCL NZdIFG D/L GCL VFJJFGL XSITF ZC[,L K[P T[JF ;\HMUMDF\ VZHNFZqVFZM5LGL HFDLG VZHL ZN SZJF VZH U]HFZ[, K[P s5f VF SFD[ A\G[ 51FSFZMGL N,L,M4 TPSPVPzLV[ ZH] SZ[, ;MU\NGFDF ;lCTGF TDFD 5M,L; 5[5;" VF TASS[ wIFG[ ,[TF\4 VF SFDGF VZHNFZq VFZM5L ;FD[ OlZIFNLGL .SM UF0L ZHLPG\P HLH[ !& 0LHLv5#() GL UF0LG]\ ;FI,g;Z H[GL lS\DT VFXZ[ ~FP&_4___qv VgI ;CVFZM5LVMGL DNNUFZLD\F RMZL SZL 0]%,LS[8 ;FI,g;Z ,UFJL VMZLHG, ;FI,g;Z ,.

H.

GF;L H.

U]GM SZ[, CMJFGF VF1F[5M K[P JW]DF\ VZHNFZqVFZM5L ;FD[GL 5M,L; T5F; DCNV\X[ 5]6" Y.

UI[,L K[P VF1F[5LT U]gCFGL .g;FOL SFI"JFCL R,FJJFGL ;tTF HI]PD[HLPOPSPzLG[ K[ VG[ VF1F[5LT U]gCFDF\ +6 JQF"GL S[NGL ;HFGL HMUJF.

K[P JW]DF\ VZHNFZqVFZM5L GFPSM8" OZDFJX[ T[JL TDFD XZTMG\] 5F,G SZJFGL BF+L VF5[ K[P T[ ;\HMUMDF\ VZHNFZqVFZM5LG[ JW] ;DI S:80LDF\ ZFBL D]SJFG\] IMuI VG[ pRLT H6FT] GYLP p5ZMST ;\HMUMDF\ VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ U]gCFDF\ EHJ[, EFU4 U]gCFGL U\ELZTF4 ;HFGL HMUJF.

VG[ S[;GF ;\HMUM wIFG[ ,. gIFIGF lCTDF\ GLR[ D]HAGM C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P vo C] S D ov s!f VZHNFZqVFZM5L D]GFJZ pO"[ D]gGF VaN], UOOFZ X[B4 ZC[P UW[DFZ4 zL BM0LIFZ DFTFGF D\lNZ 5F;[4 TFPWM/SF4 lHPVDNFJFNGFVMGL E~R XC[Z ;Lv0LJLhG 5M,L; :8[XGGF U]gCF ZHL:80" G\P!!!))__!Z#_ !(ZqZ#4 . !(ZqZ#4 .P5LP SM0GL S,Dv#*)4!!$ D]HAGF U]GFGF SFD[ OMP5PVP 4 OMP5PVPG\P **#qZ_Z# G\P**#qZ_Z# VFYL D\H]Z SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P sZf VZHNFZqVFZM5L GLR[GL SM8" ;D1F ~FP!54___qv sV\S[ ~5LIF 5\NZ CHFZ 5]ZFfGF HFT HFDLG TYF T[8,L H ZSDGF HFDLG VF%I[YL GLR[GL XZTM D]HA HFDLG D]ST SZJFGM C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P XZ T M o v o!o VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ OlZIFNL S[ OlZIFN 51FGF ;FC[NMG[ SM.56 ZLT[ WFSvWDSL VF5JL GCL T[DH SM.56 ZLT[ ,,RFJJF4 OM;,FJJF4 OM0JF 5|ItG SZX[ GCL\ S[ 5]ZFJF ;FY[ R[0F SZJF GCLP oZo VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ 5MTFGF SFIDL VG[ C\UFDL ZC[9F6GF VG[ W\WM S[ VeIF;GF ;ZGFDF 8=FI, SM8" ;D1F T[DH T5F; SZGFZ VD,NFZ ;D1F HFC[Z SZJF VG[ T[ ;ZGFDF 8=FI, SM8"GL 5ZJFGUL JUZ AN,JF GlCP o#o VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ VFWFZSF0"q5FGSF0"qZ[XGSF0"q0=FIJL\U ,FI;g; 5{SL SM.

56 N:TFJ[HGL BZL GS, HFDLG D]ST YI[YL lNGv* DF\ 8=FI, SM8" ;D1F ZH] SZJLP o$o VZHNFZqVFZM5L HM 5F;5M8" WZFJTF CMI TM HFDLG ZH] SZTL JBT[ VYJF HFDLG p5Z D]ST YIF AFN lNJ;v* DF\ 8=FI, SM8"DF\ HDF SZFJJM VG[ 5F;5M8" WZFJTF G CMI TM T[ V\U[G\] ;MU\NGFD] ZH] SZJ\]P o5o VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ T[DGL ;FD[GF[ S[; 5]6" G YFI tIF\ ;]WL 8=FI, SM8"GL 5]J" 5ZJFGUL lJGF EFZT N[XGL CN KM0JL GlCP o&o VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ SM.

U]gCFlCT 5|J'ltT S[ ;],[C XF\lT E\UGF U]gCFG\] 5]GZFJT"G G YFI T[GL SF/HL ZFBJFGL ZC[X[P o*o VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ VF U]gCFGF SFD[ RFH"XL8 G YFI tIF\ ;]WL NZ V\U[|HL DlCGFGL !

YL 5 TFZLB ;]WLDF\ ;JFZ[ !_P__ YL A5MZGF !ZP__ 5 OMP5PVPG\P **#qZ_Z# JFuIF ;]WLDF\ ;\A\WLT 5M,L; :8[XGDF\ VR]S CFHZL 5]ZFJJLP o(o VZHNFZqVFZM5LVMV[ OlZIFNL S[ ;FC[NMG[ D/J] GCL S[ D/JFGM 5|ItG SZJM GCLP s#f VZHNFZqVFZM5LV[ p5ZMST XZTMG]\ R]:T56[ 5F,G SZJ]\ VG[ T[DF\ S;]Z YI[YL VZHNFZGF HFDLG BT ZN YJFG[ 5F+ AGX[P s$f C]SDGL VD, AHJ6L ;F~ ;\A\WLT SM8"G[ T[DH ;\A\WLT 5M,L; :8[XGG[ H~ZL IFNL SZJLP C]SD VFH TFZLB !( DL DFC[ VMUQ8 ;G[ Z_Z# GF ZMH B]<,L VNF,TDF\ JF\RL ;\E/FJL HFC[Z SIM"P TFZLB o !(P_(PZ_Z# :Y/ o E~R YAP slRZFI] ;GTS]DFZ VwIF~f +LHF V[0LXG, ;[;g; HH4 E~R HLPH[P __*_*