Published on Dec 13, 2023 by [email protected]
The Delhi High Court has granted the status of a 'well-known mark' to Burger King Company LLC after the petitioner had prayed for the declaration of their trademark 'Burger King' as a well-known mark under Section 2(1)(zg) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 (TMA).
The court considered the plaintiff's long usage, extensive operations, and global reputation in declaring their trademark as a well-known mark. The plaintiff claimed to be the proprietor of the 'Burger King' trademark since 1954, operating in over 100 countries, with substantial sales and investments in promotion.
The court noted an uncanny resemblance between the logos of the parties and restrained defendants from using the petitioner's trademark but allowed the use of 'Burger Emperor.' The defendants claimed prior use of the mark since 1970 and argued for the validity of their registrations, asserting that the Burger King mark is a generic mark common to the trade. However, the court rejected the defendants' claim of the petitioner's mark being generic, considering their own applications for registration of the same.
The court referenced the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Hermes International v. Crimzon Fashion Accessories Pvt. Ltd., where the court relied on the factors outlined in Section 11(6) of the TMA to determine the well-known status of a trademark. These factors encompass the knowledge and recognition of the trademark in the relevant public, the duration, extent, and geographical area of its use and promotion, as well as the record of successful enforcement of its rights.
Three cancellation petitions under Section 57 of the TMA and a suit under Section 134 of the TMA (passing off) were filed by Burger King Company LLC against the defendants, who operated under the name and trading style of "Burger King Family Restaurant." The plaintiff sought a permanent injunction and declaration of the mark 'Burger King' as a well-known mark and relief against the defendants.
The court held that "on the strength of averments in the plaint, and the documents placed on record, and the reputation of the 'BURGER KING' mark, it is clear that it should acquire a 'well-known' status. The mark has acquired a secondary meaning in respect of burgers." All cancellation petitions were dismissed as withdrawn, and the court declared 'Burger King' to be a well-known mark.
Revolutionize legal ops with our modern Enterprise Legal Management Suite
Leading legal support provider
Awards and Recognitions