THE STATE OF GUJARAT vs KALHANS HARLAL PATEL

Case NumberSLP(C) No. 021286 - 021334 / 2021

Date of Filing4 Nov 2019

Case Type0601-Service Matters : Retiral benefits

Last Hearing17 Dec 2021

Court⚖️ Supreme Court of India ↗

StateDelhi

CityDelhi

Year of Filing2019

Petitioner

THE STATE OF GUJARAT
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
SECRETARY TO GOVT.
COMMISSIONER OF HIGHER EDUCATION
PENSION AND PROVIDENT FUND OFFICE
THE STATE OF GUJARAT EDUCATION DEPARTMENT THROUGH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
THE STATE OF GUJARAT FINANCE DEPARTMENT PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
DIRECTOR OF PENSION AND PROVIDENT FUND OFFICE
CHIEF SECRETARY GOVERNMENT OF GUJARAT
SECRETARY
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION
SECRETARY
GOVERNMENT OF GUJARAT
THE STATE OF GUJARAT THROUGH PRINCIAL SECRETARY
THE STATE OF GUJARAT EDUCATION DEPARTMENT THROUGH SECRETARY
STATE OF GUJARAT CHIEF SECRETARY
THE STATE OF GUJARAT FINANCE DEPARTMENT SECRETARY

Respondent

M.S. BHATT
H.H. DHOLAKIYA
D.A. SHASTRI
D.C. DAVE
H.C. DAVE
D.A. PATEL
B.H. NAI
A.L. BHATT
N.V. PATEL
J.R. CHAUDHARI
QAMAR S. HASAN
VILASGIRI L GOSWAMI
BRAHAMBHATT B.C.
NARAYAN K. PATEL
PARI SHAH J.B.
RASIKLAL M. MODI
K.B. BHATT
ASHOKKUMAR R. DALAL
DR. PATHY SAGUNA
TARILIKABEN R. BHAGAT
R.R. SHAH
U.V. SHAH
THAKAR B.T.
M.A. SHAH
MANGOLI V.M.
M.H. PATEL
B. NATRAJ
S.B. PANCHOLI
J.R. PATEL
B.A. PATEL
A.D. SHAH
S.M. DESAI
DR. A.K. SHAH
H F PATEL SINCE DECD. THROUGH L.H. URMILABEN
C.R. RAJANI
MANILAL H. PATEL
J.F. VALA
J.K. SOLANKI
DR. S.R. PANDYA
AJAY T OZA
RAJAGOPALAN
REKHA D. MEHTA
DILIPBHAI P. SHAH
RASHIK J. PATEL
S.G. SHAH
VITHALBHAI B. VAGHELA
C.K. SHAH
P.S. CHITTE
N.M. BHATT
M.Y. VAIJANAPURKAR
S.P. SHAH
N.R. LADHWALA
Y.U. MAHAJAN
D.M. SHAH
SMT. L.B. PETERS
INDRAVADAN C. PATEL
J.J. PRAJAPATI
Y.K. SHAH
A.N. SHAH
A.S. LOIWAL
H.P. CHAUHAN
R.H. SHAH
P.D. VYAS
M.N. PATEL
F.S. UMRIGAR
J.S. BAROT
G.N. SHAH
PATEL M K
I.H. SHETH
B.A. PATEL
M.T. DESAI
NATWARSINH K. YADAV
M.I. ZALA
N.P. CHOTAI
K.G. CHOKSHI
D.R. KORAT
K.K. SHROFF
S.D. BHATTACHARYA
A.V. OZA
N. SUBRAMANIYAM
R.M. TALVANIA
R.B. SHAH
B.T. BRAHAKSHATRI
SURESH V. JOSHI
N.T. HINGORANI
B.B. KAPURPARA
P.R. SIRSHAT
RAJANAI GIRIDHAR
HASUTA SEDANI
I V KAMALIYA
B.B. JANI
B.P. AGRAWAL
NINAZ T. ANKLESHWARIYA
B.R. DHAKAN
PROF. R.A. RAMI
D.V. GONDALIYA
S.D. TELANG
RASIKLAL C. THAKKAR
P.K. DESAI
PARUL B. DAVE
G.A. PANDOOR
DILIP MOHITE
KIRANKUMAR K. DAVE
N.G. CHRISHTIAN
RAMCHANDRAN
PRERANA MOHITE
D.B. PATEL
P.Y. MANDEY
D.M. SHAH
NARESH LAXMIPRASAD VED
BHIKHABHAI M. PATEL
DEEPAK KANNAL
GIRISH VENISHANKAR PANDYA
INDRAVADAN S. PATTANI
MANUBHAI DAHYABHAI PATEL
GIJUPRASAD RAVISHANKAR DAVE
GUNVANTLAL SOMALAL SONI
VITHALBHAI GIRDHARBHAI PATEL
MADHAVSANG SAHEBSANG RAI
NARESHKUMAR M. BHATIYA
CHHAYABEN KIRITBHAI MODI
B.A. PATEL
V.C. JANI
DILIP RAMENDRANATH BHAGCHI
VATSALKUMAR M. PATEL
BALKRISHNA ISHWARBHAI PATEL
RAMJIBHAI AMBALAL PATEL
BHAGVANBHAI DESAIBHAI PATEL
D.R.JANI
JAGDISHBHAI LALLUBHAI PATEL
ROHITBHAI DHIRUBHAI TAILOR
PRAKASH ASHVINKUMAR SHAH
PRAFULLABEN C. AMIN
AMBALAL RAMJIBHAI MAHIDA
LAXMIKER MULJIBHAI ANJARIA
D.P. SHAH
TRIKAMLAL MAGANBHAI PATEL
REGISTRAR SARDAR PATEL UNIVERSITY
SMT. C.A. SHAH
C D PATEL
SHANTABEN
N.V. VAISHAMPAYAN
REGISTRAR HEMCHANDRACHARYA NORTH GUJARAT
UNIVERSITY PATAN
DIST. PATAN
DR. KUMARPAL DESAI
G.D. PATEL
SURESHCHANDRA VISHNUPRASAD JOSHI
JAYANTIBHAI S. PATEL
P.S. SHUKLA
NISHA ANILBHAI DESAI
N.S. SUMDERMURTI
REGISTRAR GUJARAT UNIVERSITY
D.H. PATEL
PRAKASHKUMAR AMRUTLAL PUJARA
BAROT JAYANTILAL MANGALDAS
P.R. PATEL
KHARA PRATAP VANMALIDAS
P.B. JOSHI
PATEL MANUBHAI SHIVABHAI
CHANDRAVADAN C. PATEL
SHAH LALITKUMAR RAMANLAL
R.C. MARU
PATHAK PRADIPKUMAR RAMESHCHANDRA
PANCHAL RAMESHCHANDRA MANILAL
SHIRISH J. SHROFF
RAMESH J. SHAH
PATEL MADHUBHAI HARGOVINDDAS
PATEL DASHRATBHAI AMBALAL
DR. RADHEYSHYAM MADANLAL SHARMA
THE REGISTRAR GUJARAT UNIVERSITY
Y.G. DESAI
N.K.TRIVEDI
SHEKHANI BACHHRAJ SOHANLAL
S.C. DAVE
ANIL R. DESAI
HASUMATIBEN DAMODARDAS THAKKAR
D.M. GANDHI
INDIRA RAMESHCHANDRA INTWALA
RMANLAL UPADHYAY
DUDHAWAT K.P.
ARVINDKUMAR SEVANTILAL SHAH
CHITANYA H.SHAH
REGISTRAR HEMCHANDRACHARYA
NORTH GUJARAT
UNIVERSITY
B.N. PAREKH
MARKAND C. PANDYA
MADHUKANT GOBARBAI PATEL
SUKHLAL TALSHIBHAI PATEL
KEVALRAMANI BANSIDHAR MATHURDAS
SANTIKUMAR NIGAM
ISHWARBHAI V. PATIL
KIRTIBEN S. PATEL
REGISTRAR
HEMCHANDRA CHARYA NORTH GUJARAT UNIVERSITY
PATAN
SURYAKANT BHAILALBHAI PATEL
VINOD B. GOHEL
INDRAVADAN PARMANANDDAS ANANDJIWALA
REGISTRAR GUJARAT UNIVERSITY
ASHARAMBHAI LALJIBHAI PATEL
ROHITKUMAR SHANTILAL SONI
KAMUDI P. JANI
BHARATKUMAR NAGINDAS DOSHI
BIPIN C. SHAH
SHETH HASUMATIBEN NIRANJANBHAI
KOTAK ANIL KANTILAL
V.D. MEHTA
RAHIDA MOHSINBHAI ELECTRICWALA
C.D. PATHAK
THE REGISTRAR
GUJARAT UNIVERSITY
NAVRANGPURA
AHMEDABAD
R.V. TRIVEDI
VINODBHAI NANJI MISTRI
M.D. CHARADWA
BJARATI ASHOK PARIKH
BHARATIRAMANLAL DALAL
SHAH HITEN JAYANTILAL
SMT. B.K. SHAH
U.K. DESAI
A.L. PATEL
HOSKOTE SUBBARAYA RAMA
SONI RAMAN KANTILAL
M.M. PATEL
NIRANJAN MANEKLAL PANDYA
SUDHA NIRANJAN PANDYA
B.S. DALSANIA
ARTI UPENDRA NANAVATI
H.D. GAJJAR
ANUPAMA JAYANT SHAH
B.T. SHAKHIA
UPENDRA MARKANDRAY NANAVATI
G.S. PATEL
UMA GIRISHCHANDRA JOSHI
V.A. PATEL
PURSHOTTAM DINKARRAO DHUMAL
P.D. KOTAK
PALLAVI MANOJEET MEHTA
A.S. PATEL
KIRIT KANTILAL HATHI
SUDEVIBEN J. PATEL
I.V. KAMALIA
SUREKHA GANESH DEVI
PRAVINBHAI C. PATEL
I.R. PATEL
ASHA SHIVRAJ PATIL
GIRISH HIRALAL KHATRI
N.H. PATEL
SUJAY KUMAR DUTTA
DILIP KUMAR BASA
S.R. RAVAL
D.M. SHAH
AVINASH BHALCHANDRA LELE
CHOKSHI D.S.
N.N.SHETH
HARISH CHANDRA SHUKUL
THAKORE A.P.
AJAY INDUKANT TRIVEDI
S.O. SHAH
VIJAY UTTAM MATAI
V.C. SONI
I.C. SHAH
PREMJIBHAI PRABHUDAS PATEL
M.R.DAVE
SITANSHU YASHASCHANDRA MEHTA
BALKRISHNA ANKUSH PINGOLKAR
K.V. SHAH
H.V. SHUKHADIA
BHIKUBHAI MANOHARBHAI PATEL
J.V. SHAH
K.S. RANA
REGISTRAR
BHAVNAGAR UNIVERSITY
BHAVNAGAR
K.P. SINGHAL
BHAGWANBHAI MOHANBHAI CHAUDHARY
S.S. JAGDALE
REGISTRAR
ACHARYA HEMCHANDRACHARYA NORTH GUJARAT UNIVERSITY
PATAN
K.S. PATEL
S.B. PATEL
DILIP CHANDULAL SHAH
B.L. PATEL
VEER NARMAD SOUTH GUJARAT UNIVERSITY THROUGH REGISTRAR
S.A. PATEL
H.N. DESAI
D.J. PATEL
VATILAL A. PATEL
C.G. RUPARELLA
P.I. PATEL
ABDUL RAHIM KARIM SHAIKH
S.B. SHAH
SMITABEN D. KOTHARI
S.K. GOHEL
N.M. PATEL
M.B. PANCHAL
R.B. SHAH
R.K. DESAI
D.M. RAVAL
U.B. KANSARA
S.J. PARIKH
K.R. PATEL
G.T. PATEL
K.M. DESAI
L.S. PATEL
Y.A. SHELAT
Y.A. SHELAT
PATEL JAGDISH M.
H.M. TRIVEDI
A.R. SHUKLA
RANA PRADUMAN K.
H.P. PANDYA
PANCHOLI SURESH B
S.B. MEHTA
B.N. PTEL
PATEL H.P.
N.V. PRAJAPATI
N.G. SIYAT
N.K. PATEL
DEBARKAR S.G.
H.A. SHAH
SOBHABEN J. BAXI
G.R. PATEL
K.B. GALIYAL
K.P. DODIYA
S.B. PATEL
P.N. BHATT
K.P. SOLANKI
M.J. PRAJAPATI
HANSABEN J. PATEL
S.D. TRIVEDI
V.M. SHAH
M.L. DHANANI
R.K. PARGHI
SMT. GIRA Y. MANKAD
B.P. PATEL
A.M. SHAH
B.B. MAKWANA
K.V. PATEL
G.P. PURANIK
GULAM ABBAS
KALHANS HARLAL PATEL
CHANDRAVADAN RAMLAL VORA
AMARDUTTA BRAHMDUTTA VYAS
ISHWARBAI LALLUBHAI PATEL
SHANKAR GANAPATHI
MANILAL HARIDAS PATEL
SATISHCHANDRDA BALSHANKAR VORA
PRINCIPAL H.L.COLLEGE OF COMMERCE
ARVINDBHAI RANCHODLAL SHAH
ARVINDKUMAR DEVCHAND SHAH
PRAVINCHANDRA L.FARASRAM
MANGALDAS KALIDAS PATEL
VISHWANATH ANANTRAMIAH BANGALORE
SATISH KANTILAL SHAH
ABRABINDA RAY
SHANKARBHAI DAHYABHAI TRIVEDI
GOROOR SHRINIVASAN PARTHASARTHY
VISHWANATHA RAMA KARANTH
VIMALA RANGASWAMY
JAMNADAS RATILAL PATADIA
GULAMHUSEN AHMED PANDOR
JAYANTILAL SHAMJI PARMAR
PUNAMCHAND NATVERLAL SUTARIA
NAROTTAMDAS BAVABHAI PARMAR
SURESHCHHANDRA MANEKLAL DESAI
VINU HASMUKHLAL KAPADIA
JAYSHREEBASU DE
VIJAYKUMAR KARSHANBHAI MAHYAVANSHI
LALCHAND RAMCHAND MEHTA
TULSIDAS RAGHAVJI THANKI
PATEL MATHURBHAI GOPALBHAI
N.P. PATEL
PRATAPBHAI PARMAR
RAMU DULARE YADAV
K.B. MAKWANA
NAYAK RAMANLAL KESHVLAL
RAJNI J. PARIKH
BHERULAL M. KANOJA
N.C. DIXIT
K.S. THAKORE
ILAXI R. TRIVEDI
K.M. PARMAR
PRABEN H. PANDYA
BHANJI RAJARAM CHAUHAN
RAMANLAL H. PATEL
PRAHLADBHAI RAMBHAI PATEL
ARVIND M. PANDYA
SHIVRATNA R. KORI
KRUSHKANTH J. PANCHAL
INDRAVADAN S. SHAH
SURENDRA K. SHAH
MRUDULA K. KAPADIA
JAYANTILAL S. PANDYA
PRABHATSINGH CHAUHAN
RATANLAL M. PARDESHI
B.M. THAKER
MAGAN B. DABHI
ARVIND D. PATEL
D.P. SUDHAVENIYA
MANNAR K. SHAH
ARVINDBHAI H. SHAH
GAGAN A. DABHI
RAMSINH J. ZALA
LALJI L. PATEL
JAGDISH D. MEHTA
MAFAT V. DESAI
SADIWALA INDRAVADAN B.
BHAGVANDAS H. VAISHY
H.G. GOVINDA
ASHALATA J. CHHAYA
MAHENDRA K. MODI
JYOTISANA K. PANDIT
SARANG I N.
PARMAR GHANSHYAMBAI JORAVAR-SINH
RAMANBHAI MARGHABHAI PARMAR
POPAT J. THAKKAR
R.K. PARGHI
CHANDRASINH P. CHAUHAN
RAJA RAMNATH AHIR
RANJEETSINH G. AMBALA
L.J. SAUMIYA
MAFATBHAI M. DESAI
NARAN R. PATIL
JANAK C. SHAH
JYOTI R. JOSHI
D.M. PATIL
JATIN N. SHAH
C.V. PATEL
D.C. DIXIT
D.V. MOHALKAR
B.A. PRINGULKAR
ASHARAM G. PATEL
CHIMANBHAI K. VAGHELA
V.N. PARMAR
NARAN K. PARMAR
NANJIBHAI D. VAGHELA
CHANDUBHAI VANAD
KIRIT J. MEHTA
ILAXI N. SHAH
VAGHELA DC
JAYANTIBHAI H. PATEL
PATANI MS
DESAI HR
DESAI A J
PATEL DM
S A BAKHRU
DIWANJI VS
RANA JI
DESAI BB
PATEL KI
DHIMAR L J
DESAI JI
DESAI AS
BHATTO DS
DESAI NN
DESAI DIPAK I
DESAI ANITA H
DESAI DL
VAMDATT VV
PATEL LA
PATEL HANSA R
NAIK JYOTI S
K.S. YADAV
DESAI RR
R B PATIL
RANDERIA MJ
PN MAKWANA
JADEJA JH
SARANG SR
DESAI DAXA P.
SOLANKI DM
SURATI RC
HILLO H.R.
RATHOD MM
PANKAJ G DESAI
N.P. RATHOD
SN UMEKAR
R.K. PARIKH
G S GADARIYA
K P PATEL
SOLANKI MH
N G JOTANGIYA
K D VEGHELA
N K PATEL
PUSHPABEN N UMRAJWALA
VASAVDA DJ
MARJADI SI
PURHOT KT
NAIK K.T.
SONARIA C.L.
MALANKER
VJ
NAIK H.K.
PATEL LL
NAIK VA
PATEL B.K.
KAPADIA S.P.
SHAH A.R.
DR. DESAI G.C.
BHATT D.G.
SHARMA S.S.
GUPTA P.C.
DESAI B.D.
SMT. KASLIWALA B.A.
SMT.JARIWALA P.P.
SUKHADWALA T.S.
PATEL UNUS M.
SMT. PATEL MD
PATEL D.I.
DESAI H.H.
PATEL P.M.
DESAI J.J.
RAVAL S.A.
KASOTIA A.K.
MEGHANI M.V.
MAJIWALA M.P.
PATEL D.P.
BHAGAT N.D.
KHARISAHEB KU
PARMAR S.A.
PARMAR A.D.
SMT.PANTHAKI K.N.
SHROTRIYA N.A.
NAIK AR
RASHIWALA D.U.
BHUKHANWALA S.S.
PATEL S.G.
SMT. DESAI B.D.
MALI R.G.
DESAI Y.J.
GANDHI R.S.
SMT. MASTER R.J.
NAIK A.M.
PATEL V.D.
DESAI M.B.
DESAI V.M.
PATEL J.U.
RAY B.I.
DESAI Y.J.
SHETH R.S.
BHAVSAR J.G.
SHAH B.N.
PATEL S.S.
SHAH NITIN
PATEL J.V.
PATEL HEMLATA SHYMAL
DHUJWARI R.H.
PATEL D.M.
LAKHPATI KS
DESAI R.N.
PRAJAPATI B.A.
G.S. PATEL
R.C. GANDHI
B.M. DESAI
SMT. P.B. SHAH
LATE B.I. SHAH
PREMLATA BHUPENDRA SHAH
JIGARKUMAR BHUPENDRA SHAH AGED 49 YEARS
HARSHIT BHUPENDRA SHAH AGED 43 YEARS
SMT. L.R. NANAVATI
K.B. PARMAR
M.T. DALAL
LATE V.A. SHAH THROUGH LEGAL HEIR S.V. SHAH
M.Y. SEDAT
K.J. VYAS
A.S. PANDYA
MAHESH B. PATEL
R.S. SHAH
D.A. PATEL
R.G. SHAH
V.D. PARLIKAR
I.R. ITWALIA
J.D. PATEL
D.N. TANDEL
SHAH PRADIPKUMAR KANTILAL
SONI DIVYAGNABEN GUNVANTLAL
DUDHAVAT BABULAL VALLABHABHAT
PATEL TRIBHOVANBHAI MANGALBHAI
PATEL ASHABHAI RANCHODBHAI
PATEL DULABHAI GOPALBHAI
SHAH NARENDRAKUMAR NATHALAL
PRAJAPATI BHIKHABHAI GOBARBHAI
PATEL NANUBHAI SOMABHAI
DESAI HARIBHAI MOGAJIBHAI
CHAUHAN HASMUKHBHAI NANDLAL
OMPRAKASH RAMSWARUP GUPTA
SURESHCHANDRA P. MEHTA
LALJI RAMJI BALAI
NAYAK R.K.
K.K. MODI
INDRAVADAN KANTILAL SHAH
CHANDRASHANKAR
ARVINDBHAI DAHYABHAI PATEL
HARSHADRAY NARANBHAI PATEL
RAKHA S. PATEL
BHANDU D. PATEL
AMITA S. PATEL
JAYANTIBHAI SOMABHAI PATEL
VITTHALBHAI CHHOTABHAI PATEL

THE STATE OF GUJARAT and PRINCIPAL SECRETARY filed Case No. SLP(C) No. 021286 - 021334 / 2021 in the Supreme Court of India on 4 Nov 2019 against M.S. BHATT and H.H. DHOLAKIYA. The case has had one hearing so far. The case was disposed of on 17 Dec 2021. 12 orders have been issued in this matter.