Smt. Manchala Lalitha vs The State of Telangana

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdictiorr) WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF FEBRUARY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.VIJAYSEN REDDY WRIT PETITION NO:7691 OF 2022 Betwee n: 1.

Smt.

I\/anchala Lalitha, Wlo: late Shankar, aged about 4B years, Occ, Housewife.R/o.

H.

No.

6-2_54, Rampalty Viiljg;] Keesari lvandul-rvfbOiirr Malkajgiri District.

2 pm.t, l\,4anchala Laxmi,.

D/o-..

Late .Shankar, aged about 29 years, Occ.

Nil.R/o.

No 6-2-54, Rampaily Viilage, Keesara va?ai l\/edchar r,,r"rtu[i.i oiriiiii 3. sri. lr,4anchara Rahur Krishna, Sio.

Late shankar, aged about 27 years, occ.

Pvt.

Emptoyee R/o, l. .No.

6_2_54, Rampjil; Vlff"g;, -KLes"i, -rrrri.-*r'r, lr,4edchal I\,4alka1girr Distrrct.

4.

Srr. l\,4anchala Jaoan tr,,loh.q n SJo, Late Shankar, aged aboul 24 years, Occ.

Emptoyee R7o H N" 6 ,-5;,-i;,ipriry vilrg".

Keesara IVandat.

It4edchal lr/atkajgiri Distrrct.

5 Srr.

N'4anchara Nandeeshw_ar S]o.

Late Shankar, aged about 22 years, occ.

Student.Rio.

6-2-54, Rampaily Viltage X"eeirra-f,.,4anOjf, "U"Oif^rrt tr/alkajgiri District.

U 9l^l^od*^S^olla Brkshaparhy.

Sfo.

Late.Late podugoila trrla[aiah, aged abour 34 .years. ucc pvt Emptoyee.^R/ g H No 6_2_109, Rampaily Villjge Keesaia Mandal. tr,4edchal [,4atkajgiri District 7.

Sri.

Misala chinna Baraiah, S/o.

Late Misara pedda Narsarah, aged about 62 Years, occ.

Agricutture.R/o .H No.

6-2_6, SC a"b"t; R;;;;ly"fiilg; Keesa ra I\/a nda I, l\,4edcha I lVal kajg iri District.

B l,]^Ml.^1|i ,S.*-1rr*,!,q Late I\,4isala pedda Narsaiah, aged abour 60 years, ucc. r\gflcutture.

R/o.

N9, 6.2_6 SC Cotony, Rampjtty Village, keesal Irrla n d a L lr,4ed c ha I lrila I k a j g i ri D i st rict.

9. sri.

Misala Yadag]ri, s/o.

Late Misara pedda Narsaiah, aged about 57 years.

9cc Agricurture.R/o.

H.. \o. g_?_6, SC Cotony, n;rirrlty"V,iir"d","k"*;; Ivlandal, Ir/edchal Ir,4atkajqiri District.

10.sri.

Ir/isala IMallesh, s/o. lesh, s/o.

Late Misala pedda Narsaiah, aoed about 54 years.

Occ.

Agricutture.R/o.

6-2-6, SC Coronv,-ii;prlty V,ltil;"K,i*;; Mandal, t\.4edchal IMalkajgiri District. '1 1 .

Meesala Balaiah, S/o._ Late Muthaiah, aged about 75 years, Occ.

6-2-7, Ramparty virige: xeeilii'rrrr*aui-rrrrboi.ui lValkajgiri District.

12 Sri..lVeesala Yadagiri, S/o. l\,4eesala Balaiah, aqed about 48 years, Occ.

Agriculture.R/o.

6-2-7, Rampally Village, "Keesa* Ma;da[-Idd;;;i Malkajgiri District.

13.

Meesala Laxmamma, Sio.

Late lvleesala Pochaiah, aged about 66 Years, Occ.

Hc.rsewife.R/o.

6-2-7, Rampally Village.

Keesara lMandal, lvledchal Malka 3iri District.

14.Smt.

Late Meesala Pochaiah, aged about 66 Years, Occ. l- cusewife.Rio, H.

6-2-125, Rampally Village, Keesara Mandal, I\/edch rl tr/alkajgiri District.

15.

Sri, tr,4eesala Bi rshapathi, S/o.

Late lvleesala Pochaiah, aged about 52 Years, Occ.

Agricultur:.R/o.

6-2-125, Rampally Village, Keesara lVarrdal, N/edchal IMalka liri District. '16.

Sri. l\4eesala l! allesh, S/o.

Late ltrleesala Pochaiah, aged about 38 Years, Occ.

Agricultur r R/o.

6-2-'125, Rampally Village, Keesara I\,4andal, lVledchal Malkaj yiri District. 'l 7.

N4eesala As rok, S/o.

Late I\,4eesala Pochaiah, aged about 36 Years, Occ.

Agriculture.

6-2-125, Rampally Village, Keesara [t4andal, tt4edchal lValkajgiri Distrir t.

18.

I\/eesala S inivas, S/o.

Late It/.

Pedda Yadaiah,aged about 45 Years, Occ.

Agricultur r.R/o.

6-2-37, Rampally Village, Keesara Mandal, Medchal lMalkaj liri District.

19.

Sri. lvleesala lV rhipal, S/o.

Late lt/eesala Pochaiah, aged about 44 Years, Occ.

Agricr lture.R/o.

No.6-2-37, Rampally Village Keesara lVIandal, tvledchal l\/alkaj liri District.

20.

Nallola Mal ender, S/o.

Late Yadaiah, aged about 46 Years, Occ.

Agriculture.R/o. {.

No. /o. {.

6-1-3711, Rampally Village, Keesara l\4andal, I\zledchal Malkajgiri Distri( t.

2'1 .

Nallola Ku rar, S/o.

Late Yadaiah, aged about 45 Years, Occ.

R/o. -.1.

6-1-3711, Rampally Village, Keesara I\4andal, [r,ledchal It/alkajgiri Distric .

22, Sri.

Nallola Ma: thanbabu, S/o.

Late Pedda Balaiah, aged about 35 Years, Occ.

Agric :lture.

R/ o.

6-2-103, Rampally Village.

Keesara l\,4andal, Medchz I lr4alkalgiri District.

23.

Sri. [r,4anchala lV rsaiah, S/o.

Late Pedda Mysaiah, aged about (]1 Years.

Retd.

Employee R/o.

6-2-53/1, Rampally Village, Keesara l\,4andal. tvledchal lt4alkajl iri District.

24.

Sri. lVanchala K ishna, S/o.

Late Pedda tVysaiah, aged about ti3 Years, Occ.

Agriculture R/o.

L No.

6-2-5311, Rampally Village, Keesara lvlandal, ll4edchal tr/alka.lgiri Distric .

25- Sri. l\,4anchala Lz xman, S/o.

Late Pedda Mysaiah, aged about 51 Years, Occ.

Employee.

6-2-53/1 , Rampally Village, Keesara [/andal, Medchal lValkajg ri District.

26.

Sri. lrlanchala N rrsing Rao, S/o.

Ir/.

Chinna Mysaiah, aged about 40 Years, Occ.

Emplc yee.Rl/o.

6-2-86,Rampally Village, Keesara [r,4andal, Medchal Malkajg ri District.

27.

Sri. fVlanchala K rmar, S/o.

M.

Chinna Mysaiah, aged about 38 Years, Occ.

6-2-86,Rampally Village, Keesara lvlandal, Ivledchal Malkajg ri District.

AND ..PET|TTONER(S) '1 .

The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue Department (Stamps and Registration), BRK Bhavan, Secretariat, Hyderabad.

2.

The Commissioner and lnspector General of Stamps and Registration, tr,4ozamjahi Market Hydera bad, Telanga na State.

3.

The District Registrar, I\/edchal IMalkajgiri dist.

Medchal.

The Sub Registrar, Keesara, Keesara lt4andal, IVledchal-Malkajgiri District. ,.. trict. ,..RESPONDENTS Petition Under Article 226 oI lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavlt filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of lvlandamus declaring the action of the respondents No.4 in not receiving processing registering and releasing the document, presented by the pelitioners in respect of plot bearing No. '1 1 and 21 each admeasuring 200 sq.yads, 47 admeasuring 167 and 48 and 49 admeasuring 250 sq.yards, B5 and 86 admeasuring 230 sq. yards and plot bearing No.

119 admeasuring 300 sq. yards all the plots situated at lt4adhuranagar Colony, Rampally village, Nagaram tvluniclpality , Keesara lVlandal, tvledchal Malkaigiri District. in view of the lVlemo No G2t25712019 clated 261812020 passed by the 2nd respondent as being illegal arbitrary violative of articles of 14 21 and 300A of constitution of lndia besides violative of principles of natural justice and contrary to the Registration Act 1908 and also in violation of the orders passed by the Division bench of this Honorable court in writ Petition No 9248 of 2021 and to consequently direct the 4th respondent to receive process register and release the sale deed in respect of plot bearing No.

11 and 21 each admeasuring 200 sq.yads' 47 admeasuring 167 and 48 and 49 admeasuring 250 sq.yards, B5 and 86 admeasuring 230 sq. yards and plot bearing No.

119 acimeasuring 300 sq. yards all the plots situated at lVladhuranagar colony, Rampally village, Nagaram lt/unicipality , Keesara lt4andal, Ir,4erlchal lr/alkajgiri District. notwithstanding the l\,4emo G2125712O19 daled 26t8t2020. t.A.NO.1 0F 2022 Petition Under iection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in I upport of the petitiorr. petitiorr. the High Court nlay be pleased to direct the 4th responr ent to receive, process, register and release the sale deed in respect of the plot bearing No, '1 1 and 21 each admeasuring 200 sq yads, 47 admeasuring 167 a rd 48 and 49 admeasuring 250 sq.yards, 85 and 86 admeasuring 230 sq. yards ancl plot bearing No.

1 19 admeasuring 300 sq. yards all the plots situate I at Madhuranagar colony, Rampally village, Nagaranr Municipality, Keesari lvlandal, Medchal lr/alka.igiri District. notwithsta nd ing the Memo issued by the ! nd respondent, pending disposal of the writ petition Counsel for the Petit rners : SRI.POLICE VENKAT REDDY Counsel for the Resp rndents : AGP FOR REVENUE The Court made the I rllowing ORDEII HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.

VIJAYSEN REDDY WRIT PETITION No.7591 OF 2022 ORDER: Heard both sides and perused the material on record.

It is submitted by the learned counsel on either side that subject matter of this Writ Petition is squarely covered by the Common Order passed by this Court in W.P.No.328 ot 2022 and batch dated 18.O2.2022 as modified by the Order dared 22.O2.2022 in I.A.No.2 of 2022 in W.P.No.2985 of 2022 and batch, as such, this Writ Petition may be disposed of in terms thereof.

Therefore, lollowing the Common Order dated I8.O2.2O22 in W.

P.

No.328 of 2022 and batch as modified by the Order dated 22.02.2022 in I.A.

No.2 of 2022 in W.P.No.2985 of 2022, in terms thereof, this Writ Petition is disposed of as under without any order as to costs: (i) The respondent - Sub-Registrar is directed to register the document of sale, transfer and gift etc., presented for registration by the petitioner/s without references to the Memo Nos.G2l257 /2019 dated 26.Oa.2O2O and 29.12.2020 issued by the respondent - the Commissioner and Inspector General of Registration and Stamps, Telangana; Letter No.4S/TP/ NMC/2019 dated 01.11. ted 01.11.2019 issued by the respondent - the Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Nizampet to lhe respondent - the Sub Registrar, Quthbullapur, Ranga Recldy District, and similar letters, if any, issued blr thc various Mtrnicipal Commissioners in the Statei (ii) t-re Sub Registrars in the State shall make an endorsement at the reverse side of the first page of the tlocument refcrred in dire:tion No.(i) that registration so done is subject to outcome of SLF (Civil) No.19695 of 2O2l filed by the State Government bef( re the Hon'ble Supreme Court; and (iii) n case, it is founcl that there is any violation o[ larv like plots / lz nds / structures being sold form part of tr'T L i'rnd Buffcr Zor '- I Plots having less than 30 feet road width :rccess' tl're Sulr Reg strar shall make an endorsement informing / cautior-ring thc pur:hasers that risk is involved in purchasc of sttch plotsl such trar sactions are hit by relevant st'tttltor\ ilrovi'sior.ts; thtrt rcg, stration of the same is sullject to oulconlc o[ orrlcrs ol'tttc Hor 'ble Supremc Court in SLP {Civil) No 19695 rtf 2{)21' To that clfc:t, an enclorscmcllt shall bc made on thc rcvt'rsc' sirle o[ tl'rc llr-. / scct.rncl llil l-lc ol tllc (locLllrellL rltcl iilsLr iti illt' cr-rt ,unbtitnce rccorcl. u'cl;site ctc' The mis< ellaneous pctitions pending, if any' shall stancl closccl There shall be to order as to costs' //TRUE COPY// SD/-K.SAILESHI ASSISTANT REGISTRAR i-r SECTION OFFICER To The Principal )ecretary, Revenue Department l:t?rnPt arrd Registration) BRK Bhavan, Secretarrat Siuiu ot f"iungana Hyderaba(l r.he commiss oner and ,nrpJiioi Ou*rit o-t Str.pt and Reqrstration' Ni ;"#il il i i,i,ir, " i u v J"'u n' o Tr"j?-:: 3 ll ir::?J,?i, " o. n o, i[:"".,}:{}[l?Eil#"#Ei,t"r::tr:H'rry;:lh':siisi:8:'i:'i' Hi"St?j JlilJAr,"t vENKAr REDDY' Advocate toPucl 1.

5.

6 7 B SA SB Two CD CoPl :s One sPare cc lY ${' HIGH COURT DATED:2310212022 ORDER WP.No.7691 of 2022 DISPOSING OF THE W,P WITHOUT COSTS. € 7. s :.. € 7. s :.. it) l,{AH 7 I ( ? :) { o \ 1a) AA{}