K.C.Vinayaka vs The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner
Party Details
- K.C.Vinayaka
- The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner
Case Summary
K.C.Vinayaka filed Case No. CC/544/2015 in the Consumer Court on 14 Aug 2015 against The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner. The case has undergone 8 hearings over 6 months. The case is currently pending. 1 order has been issued in this matter.
Hearing History (8)
- 4MAR 2016Hearing
Judge: N/A
Stage: DISPOSED OFF
- 26FEB 2016Hearing
Judge: N/A
Stage: FINAL HEARING
- 3FEB 2016Hearing
Judge: N/A
Stage: FINAL HEARING
Orders (1)
- 4MAR 2016judgement
Order No: N/A
Judgement Details
Cause Title/Judgement-Entry DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM MYSURU No.1542 F, Anikethana Road, C and D Block, J.C.S.T.
Layout, Kuvempunagara, Kuvempunagara, (Behind Jagadamba Petrol Bunk), Mysuru-570023 Complaint Case No.
CC/538/2015 1.
A.S.Joshi S/o Late Srinivasacharya Joshi, 63 years, B1/15, BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner EPF Organization Sub Regional Office, Bhavishanidhi Bhavan, No.109-128, 2nd Stage, Gayathripuram, Mysuru-570019. ............Opp.Party(s) Complaint Case No.
CC/539/2015 1.
S.Jayaram S.Jayaram, S/o Late Srinivasa Iyengar, 62 years, 1st B lock, D.No.2, BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023 ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/540/2015 1.
N.Eswarappa S/o Late Nanjappa, 63 years, No.7, Block No.20, Srikasha, BEML Nagar, Srirampura, Mysuru-570023 ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/541/2015 1.
S.R.Narayan S/o Late B.Ramegowda, 62 years, No.02, Block No.26, BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/542/2015 1.
K.S.Prabhakara S/o Late K.Shankar Narayana, 62 years, Block No.25, Site No.4, BEML Layout, 1st Stage, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023 ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner EPF Organization Sub Regional Office, Bhavishanidhi Bhavan, No. havan, No.109-128, 2nd Stage, Gayathripuram, Mysuru-570019. ............Opp.Party(s) Complaint Case No.
CC/543/2015 1.
R.Lakshminarayana Rao S/o Late N.P.Rudrappa Rao, 64 years, No.1129, 5th Main, Vivekananda Nagar, Mysuru-570023.. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/544/2015 1.
K.C.Vinayaka Joi, 62 years, No.175, MIG A Block, 6th Main, 3rd Stage, Vijayanagar, Mysuru-570017. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/545/2015 1.
S.Sampathkumar Deekshit S/o Late Shankara Narayana.S., 63 years, No.17, Block No.27, BEML 1st Stage, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/546/2015 1.
Somanatha.D.R.
S/o Late H.S.Ramappa, 60 years, No.847, 2nd Main, 2nd Cross, Aravinda Nagar, Mysuru-570023. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/547/2015 1.
Dathathraya S/o Late H.B.Shamana, 61 years, No.409, 2/1, Main Road, 1st Block, Ramakrishna Nagar, Mysuru-570022. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/548/2015 1.
Y.M.Suryanarayana Rao S/o Y.Manjaiah, 62 years, No. years, No.L-12, 1st Cross, 3rd B Main, I Block, Ramakrishnagar, Mysuru-570022. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/549/2015 1.
S.S.Ranga Swamy S/o S.V.Seetha Ramaiah, 64 years, No.404, 12th Cross, 2nd Stage, Srirampura, Mysuru-570023. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/550/2015 1.
Nagesh.C.
S/o M.K.Chandrashekaraiah, 60 years, No.56, 6th Cross, Kashyapa, K.R.Vanam, Chamaraja Mohalla, Mysuru-570008. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/551/2015 1.
Shivaramu.M.
S/o Late H.N.Mariyappa, 61 years, No.1124, 9th Main, 3rd Stage, 1st Floor, Gokulam, V.V.Mohalla, Mysuru-570002. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/552/2015 1.
Shivaraju S/o Late S.D.Govindegowda, 66 years, No.3594, 20th Main, 1st Cross, Vijayanagar, 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570017. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/553/2015 1.
Vijayakumar.H.
S/o Late Hanumaiah, 60 years, No.20, Block 11, Pranathi, BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
Versus 1.
CC/554/2015 1.
B.A.Phaneendra Kumar S/o B.S.Aswatha Murthy, 61 years, No.MIG 37, E & F Block, 1st Stage, Ramakrishna Nagara, Mysuru-570022. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/555/2015 1.
V.Nagaraja S/o Late Venkatanarayanappa, 59 years, D.No.2891/1F, Basaveshwara Road, Chamundipuram, Mysuru-570004. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/556/2015 1.
J.N.Jayaram S/o Late J.K.Narasimhaswamy, 60 years, No.4327, 6th Cross, 17th Main, Vijayanagar, 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570017. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/557/2015 1.
Sandhya A.Shreekanth D/o Late J.N.Sathyanarayana, 60 years, No.19, Dattatreya Nilaya, Main Jayalakshmipuram, Mysuru-570012. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/558/2015 1.
M.Puttaswamy S/o Late Kempaiah, 67 years, No.258, 1st cross, Niveditha Nagar, Mysuru-570023. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner EPF Organization Sub Regional Office, Bhavishanidhi Bhavan, No.109-128, 2nd Stage, Gayathripuram, Mysuru-570019. ............ ..........Opp.Party(s) Complaint Case No.
CC/559/2015 1.
Dwarakanath.K.
S/o Late Krishna Iyengar, 61 years, No.12, B7 BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/560/2015 1.
Manjunath.K.S.
S/o Sathyanarayana.c., 63 years, No.27, Block-5, Madhuvana Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
CC/561/2015 1.
K.S.Nataraju S/o Late G.C.Shivabasappa, 61 years, No.3600, 16th Cross, R.P.Road, Near Kalamandira Nanjangudu, Mysuru-571301. ...........Complainant(s) Versus 1.
The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner EPF Organization Sub Regional Office, Bhavishanidhi Bhavan, No.109-128, 2nd Stage, Gayathripuram, Mysuru-570019. ............Opp.Party(s) BEFORE: HON'BLE MR.
H M Shivakumara Swamy PRESIDENT HON'BLE MS.
M V Bharthi MEMBER HON'BLE MR.
Devakumar M.C MEMBER For the Complainant: For the Opp.
Party: ORDER BEFORE THE DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM, MYSORE-570023 CONSUMER COMPLAINT NOS.538 to 561-2015 DATED ON THIS THE 4th March 2016 Present: 1) Sri.
H.M.Shivakumara Swamy B.A., LLB., - PRESIDENT 2) Smt.
M.V.Bharathi B.Sc., LLB., - MEMBER 3) Sri.
Devakumar.M.C.
B.E., LLB., - MEMBER CC 538/15 : A.S.Joshi, S/o Late Srinivasacharya Joshi, 63 years, No.B1/15, BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023.
CC 539/15 : S.Jayaram, S/o Late Srinivasa Iyengar, 62 years, 1st Block, D.No.2, BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023.
CC 540/15 : N.Eswarappa, S/o Late Nanjappa, 63 years, No.7, Block No.20, Sriraksha, BEML Nagar, Srirampura, Mysuru-570023.
CC 541/15 : S.R.Narayan, S/o Late B. /o Late B.Ramegowda, 62 years, No.02, Block No.26, BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023.
CC 542/15 : K.S.Prabhakar, S/o Late K.Shankar Narayan, 62 years, Block No.25, Site No.4, BEML Layout, 1st Stage, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023.
CC 543/15 : R.Lakshminarayana Rao, S/o Late N.P.Rudrappa Rao, 64 years, No.1129, 5th Main, Vivekananda Nagar, Mysuru-570023.
CC 544/15 : K.C.Vinayaka, S/o Late K.Chidambara Jois, 62 years, 175, MIG A Block, 6th Main, 3rd Stage, Vijayanagar, Mysuru-570017.
CC 545/15 : S.Sampathkumar Deekshit, S/o Late Shankara Narayana.S., 63 years, 17, Block No.27, BEML 1st Stage, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023.
CC 546/15 : Somanatha.D.R., S/o Late H.S.Ramappa, 60 years, No.847, 2nd Main, 2nd Cross, Aravinda Nagar, Mysuru-570023.
CC 547/15 : Dathathraya, S/o Late H.B.Shamanna, 61 years, 409, 2/1, Main Road, 1st Block, Ramakrishna Nagar, Mysuru-570022.
CC 548/15 : Y.M.Suryanarayana Rao, S/o Y.Manjaiah, 62 years, L-12, 1st Cross, 3rd B Main, I Block, Ramakrishnagar, Mysuru-570022.
CC 549/15 : S.S.Ranga Swamy, S/o S.V.Seetha Ramaiah, 64 years, No.404, 12th Cross, 2nd Stage, Srirampura, Mysuru-570023.
CC 550/15 : Nagesh, S/o M.K.Chandrashekaraiah, 60 years, No.56, 6th Cross, Kashyapa K R Vanam, Chamaraja Mohalla, Mysuru-570008.
CC 551/15 : Shivaramu.M., S/o Late H.N.Mariyappa, 61 years, No.1124, 9th Main, 3rd Stage, 1st Floor, Gokulam, V.V.Mohalla, Mysuru-570002.
CC 552/15 : Shivaraju, S/o Late S.D.Govindegowda, 66 years, No.3594, 20th Main, 1st Cross, Vijaynagar, 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570017.
CC 553/15 : Vijaya Kumar.H., S/o Late Hanumaiah, 60 years, No.20, Block 11, Pranathi, BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023.
CC 554/15 : B.A.Phaneendra Kumar, S/o B.S.Aswath Murthy, 61 years, No.MIG 37, E & F Block, 1st Stage, Ramakrishna Nagara, Mysuru-570022.
CC 555/15 : Nagaraj.V., S/o Late Venkatanarayanappa, 59 years, D.No.2891/1F, Basaveshwara Road, Chamundipuram, Mysuru-570004.
CC 556/15 : Jayaram.J.N., S/o Late J.K.
Late J.K.Narasimhaswamy, 60 years, No.4327, 6th Cross, 17th Main, Vijayanagar, 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570017.
CC 557/15 : Sandhya A.Sreekanth, D/o Late J.N.Sathyanarayana, 60 years, No.19, Dattatreya Nilaya, Main Jayalakshmipuram, Mysuru-570012.
CC 558/15 : M.Puttaswamy, S/o Late Kempaiah, 67 years, No.258, 1st Cross, Niveditha Nagar, Mysuru-570023.
CC 559/15 : Dwarakanath.K., S/o Late Krishna Iyengar, 61 years, No.123, B 7 BEML Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru-570023.
CC 560/15 : Manjunath.K.S., S/o Sathyanarayana.C., 63 years, No.27, Block-5, Madhuvana Layout, Srirampura 2nd Stage, Mysuru.
CC 561/15 : K.S.Nataraju, S/o Late G.C.Shivabasappa, 61 years, No.3600, 16th Cross, R.P.Road, Near Kalamandira Nanjangud, Mysuru-571301. (Smt.G.Geetha Bai, Advocate) V/S Opponent is common in all the 24 cases : The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, EPF Organization Regional Office Bhavishyanidhi Bhavan, No.109-128, 2nd Stage, Gayathripuram, Mysore-570019. (Sri.
A.V.Jayarama Rao, Advocate) Nature of complaint : Deficiency in service Date of filing of complaint : 14.08.2015 Date of Issue notice : 21.08.2015 Date of order : 04.03.2016 Duration of Proceeding : 6 MONTHS 20 DAYS Sri H.M.SHIVAKUMARA SWAMY, President COMMON ORDER IN CC Nos.
538 to 561/2015 These are the complaints filed by the members of Employees Pension Scheme of 1995, with a request to direct the opposite party to refix the pension and to pay the arrears from the date of retirement till the same is refixed with interest and also to pay the refixed rate of pension in future, for damages and costs of the proceedings.
The opposite party appeared and filed the detailed objections though admitted that the complainants in different complaint numbers are the members of their organization, there is no deficiency of service.
Thereby sought for dismissal of all the complaint. complaint.
Since, the reliefs sought for by all the complainants in these complaints are similar and the opposite party is one establishment, thereby all these matters are clubbed together for disposal.
In all the cases, the complainants filed their respective affidavit evidence, likewise the opposite party also filed its affidavit.
After hearing both sides, these matters are set down for orders.
The points that arise for consideration of this Forum are as follows:- Whether the complainants establishes that the opposite party failed to fix the pension properly in accordance with para 12(3), 12(4) and 12(5)(a)&(b) R/w para 10(2) of Employees Pension Scheme of 1995, thereby there is deficiency of service on the part of the opposite party and as such the complainants are entitled for the reliefs?
What order?
Our findings on the aforesaid points are as follows: Point No.1 :- Partly in the affirmative.
Point No.2 :- As per final order for the following :: R E A S O N S :: Point No.1:- It is the case of the complainants in general that they are the members of Employees Family Pension Scheme 1971 and contributed to the said fund as per section 6 A of the said scheme.
Subsequently, the Government has formulated Employees Pension Scheme 1995 w.e.f.
01.04.1993.
The said scheme has been opted by the complainants from the inception.
The contribution made towards Employees Family Pension Scheme 1971, has been transferred to Employees Pension Fund under the New Scheme.
All the complainants have contributed to the Employees Fund from 1971 till the date of their respective retirement.
The opposite party is the officer appointed under the scheme becomes the service provider to the complainants and the complainants become Consumers as per section 2(d) of C.P.Act.
As per the new scheme, those who have completed more than 20 years of service and retired on attaining age of superannuation at the age of 58 years are eligible for additional weightage of 2 years service. s service.
Thereby the opposite party while fixing the pension ought to have taken into consideration, the two years weightage provided under the scheme.
In some cases minimum pension not fixed as per para 12(3) and past service benefits in para 12(5)(a) and (b) of the scheme.
The opposite party without looking into these aspects fixed the pension, thereby there is difference in the pension fixed to the present respective complainants.
Thereby, it is necessary to direct the opposite party to refix the pension as per paras 12(3), 12(4) and past service benefits as per para 12(5)(a) and (b) R/w 10(2) and to pay arrears from the respective date of retirement and also to add the difference to the future pension with interest and also for payment of damages and costs of these complaints.
With this pleadings of complainant what exactly the pleadings of opposite party is to be taken into consideration and apart from denial of the liability, the opposite party intends to interpret the scheme in the different manner and sought for dismissal of all the complaints.
The Forum has to see the past service and the actual service of each complainant.
The table shown below reveals the said fact:- Sl.
No.
Case No.
Complainant Name Duty Joining Year Date of Retirement Past Service Actual Service Eligible service 1 CC 538/15 A.S.Joshi 1973 03.09.2010 21 Y 11 M 4 D 14 Y 9 M 17 D 37 Y 2 CC 539/15 S.Jayaram 1974 04.01.2011 21 Y 4 M 27 D 15 Y 1 M 20 D 37 Y 3 CC 540/15 N.Eswarappa 1972 01.11.2010 22 Y 6 M 15 D 14 Y 11 M 16 D 38 Y 4 CC 541/15 S.R.Narayan 1974 05.09.2011 21 Y 4 M 15 D 15 Y 9 M 21 D 37 Y 5 CC 54215 K.S.Prabhakar 1974 29.11.2011 21 Y 18 D 16 Y 14 D 37 Y 6 CC 543/15 R.Lakshminarayana Rao 1977 17.09.2009 18 Y 14 Y 32 Y 7 CC 544/15 K.C.Vinayaka 1975 14.04.2011 20 Y 3 M 15 Y 5 M 36 Y 8 CC 545/15 S.Sampathkumar Deekshit 1981 02.04.2010 13 Y 8 M 14 D 14 Y 4 M 16 D 28 Y 9 CC 546/15 Somanatha.D.R.
1975 08.01.2013 19 Y 11 M 8 D 17 Y 1 M 24 D 37 Y 10 CC 547/15 Dathathraya 1974 11.04.
974 11.04.2012 20 Y 7 M 15 D 16 Y 4 M 27 D 37 Y 11 CC 548/15 Y.M.Suryanarayana 1975 08.04.2011 19 Y 10 M 4 D 15 Y 4 M 24 D 35 Y 12 CC 549/15 S.S.Ranga Swamy 1975 02.01.2009 20 Y 13Y 33 Y 13 CC 550/15 Nagesh.C.
1979 19.05.2013 15 Y 10 M 15 D 17 Y 6 M 4 D 33 Y 14 CC 551/15 Shivaramu.M.
1974 30.11.2012 21 Y 5 M 15 D 17 Y 15 D 39 Y 15 CC 552/15 Shivaraju 1971 17.02.2007 24 Y 11 Y 35 Y 16 CC 553/15 Vijaya Kumar.H.
1985 19.02.2013 9 Y 6 M 15 D 17 Y 3 M 4 D 27 Y 17 CC 554/15 B.A.Phaneendra Kumar 1982 11.06.2012 13 Y 1 M 15 D 16 Y 6 M 27 D 30 Y 18 CC 555/15 Nagaraja.V.
1986 30.06.2014 8 Y 6 M 15 D 18 Y 7 M 15 D 27 Y 19 CC 556/15 Jayaram.J.N.
1980 04.02.2013 14 Y 7 M 15 D 17 Y 2 M 20 D 32 Y 20 CC 557/15 Sandya A.Sreekanth 1988 21.09.2013 7 Y 2 D 17 Y 10 M 6 D 25 Y 21 CC 558/15 M.Puttaswamy 1971 11.06.2006 24 Y 11 Y 35 Y 22 CC 559/15 Dwarakanath.K.
1974 04.11.2012 20 Y 10 M 15 D 16 Y 11 M 20 D 30 Y 23 CC 560/15 Manjunath.K.S. (56 y Rtd.) 1982 31.03.2007 13 Y 11 Y 4 M 15 D 24 Y 24 CC 561/15 K.S.Nataraju 1974 11.04.2012 20 Y 7 M 15 D 16 Y 4 M 27 D 37 Y Y – Years, M – Months, D – Days The above table discloses the past service as well as actual service rendered by each complainants who served for more than 20 years and retired on attaining the age of superannuation at 58 years.
Thereby there is no short fall of past service or actual service, as such the authorities that is opposite party ought to have fixed the pension by giving 2 years weightage to each complainant as per the provisions of para 12 (3) and (4) R/w section para 10(2) of Employees Pension Scheme of 1995, and not fixed the minimum pension in some cases as per para 12(3) and past service benefits in para 12(5)(a) and (b) of the scheme, that is absent while fixing the pension of each complainant in these cases and there is deficiency in service on the part of the opposite party. ite party.
Further, the counsel representing the complainants relied on several judgements of the Hon’ble National Commission as well as by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
The Revision Petition No.2238/2014 – Regional Provident Fund Commissioner – Vs – H.G.Vijaykumar and another.
The Revision Petition No.3970/2009 – Regional Provident Fund Commissioner – Vs – Sri Mallikarjun Devendrappa Verapur.
The said judgement of National Commission has been challenged by the Provident Fund Authorities in Special Leave Petition to Appeal No.30844/2010 which was dismissed by the Supreme Court at the admission stage itself.
ILR 2004 KAR 2859 – K.Chennakesavalu –Vs- Employees Provident Fund Organisation by its Commissioner.
Revision Petition No.1328/2013 – National Commission – Asst.
Provident Fund Commissioner – Vs – Rangarao.
Based on these judgements, the counsel representing the complainants submits that the calculation of the pension by the opposite party is not correct and while calculating the pension under the Employees Pension Scheme of 1995, the weightage of 2 years ought to have been given to each complainant while fixing the pension on retirement, that has not been done in these cases.
Thereby there is deficiency of service.
The said arguments of complainants’ side is supported by the latest judgement of the Hon’ble National Commission reported in III (2015) CPJ 3 (NC) (RPF, Commissioner –vs- C.Raghavendrachar and others).
In view of the discussions made above and in view of several judgements referred by the complainant’s advocate, this Forum finds that the opposite party has not properly calculated the pension with reference to para 12(4) R/w para 10(2) of Employees Pension Scheme of 1995 and in some cases minimum pension not fixed as per para 12(3) and past service benefits in para 12(5)(a) and (b) of the scheme.
Thereby, now the opposite party is to be directed to correct the mistake committed while fixing the pension of each complainant.
Hence, the point No. point No.1 is answered partly in affirmative.
Point No.2:- In view of the above findings recorded on Point No.1, all the complainants are entitled to succeed in these complaints.
Hence, we pass the following :: COMMON ORDER IN CC 538 to 561/2015 :: The complaints filed by the complainants under section 12 of the C.P.Act are allowed in part.
The opposite party is directed to refix the pension as per para 12(4) R/w para 10(2) of Employees Pension Scheme of 1995 by adding 2 years weightage to the service of each complainant from the date of respective retirement within 2 months from the date of this order.
The opposite party is directed to fix minimum pension as per para 12(3) and past service benefits as per para 12(5)(a) and (b) of the scheme wherever required.
Further, the opposite party is directed to pay the arrears with interest at 9% p.a. from the date of these complaints till payment is made.
Further, the opposite party is directed to pay Rs.2,000/- to each complainant towards the litigation expenses.
In case of default to comply this order, the opposite parties shall undergo imprisonment and also liable for fine under section 27 of the C.P.Act, 1986.
Keep original order in C.C.538/2015 and Xerox copies of the order in C.C.539 to 561/2015.
Give the copies of this order to the parties, as per Rules. (Dictated to the Stenographer transcribed, typed by her, transcript corrected by us and then pronounced in open court on this the 4th March 2015) (H.M.SHIVAKUMARA SWAMY) PRESIDENT (M.V.BHARATHI) (DEVAKUMAR.M.C.) MEMBER MEMBER [HON'BLE MR.
H M Shivakumara Swamy] PRESIDENT [HON'BLE MS.
M V Bharthi] MEMBER [HON'BLE MR.
Devakumar M.C] MEMBER