RAGHVENDRA NAG (M) , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , vs REVENUE CBIC (M) , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT , DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT ,

OA/450/2021 Page 1 of 6 CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL HYDERABAD BENCH OA/020/450/2021 HYDERABAD, this the 27th day of August, 2021 Hon’ble Mr.

Ashish Kalia, Judl.

Member Hon’ble Mr.

Tarun Shridhar, Admn.

Member 1.

Raghavendra Nag, S/o.

Late Shri Sukhlal Nag, Aged about 37 years, Group.

B, Occ:Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Visakhapatnam, CGST Audit, Commissionerate, R/o.

Visakhapatnam, [email protected] , Ph: 9160009253.

2.

Raju Kumar, S/o.

Late Shri Raghunath Prasad, Aged about 43 years, Group.

B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Visakhapatnam, [email protected], Ph:7780380224.

3.

Rajesh Roshan, S/o.

M.S.

Manoj, Aged about 40 years, Group.

Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, Vijayawada, Email:[email protected] Ph: 9849274703.

4.

Shatrudhan Prasad Singh, S/o.

Late Janardan Choudhary, Aged about 33 years, Group.

Visakhapatnam, Guntur Audit Commissionerate, R/o.

Visakhapatnam, Email:[email protected], Ph:8099560294.

5.

Sudhanshu Shekhar, S/o.

Late Sachhidanand Mishra, Aged about 40 years, Group.

Visakhapatnam, Email:[email protected], Ph:7702862432.

6.

M.

Vittal Rao, S/o.

Venkat Rao, Aged about 51 years, Group.

Dacheppali Range, Guntur Division, OA/450/2021 Page 2 of 6 Guntur Commissionerate, Vizag Zone, R/o.

Dacheppali, Email:[email protected], Ph:9849641175.

7.

Srinivas Reddy, S/o.

Late M.V.

Krishna Reddy, Aged about 51 years, Group.

Divisional Office, CGST Kadapa Division, Tirupathi Commissionerate, Vizag Zone, R/o.

Kadappa, Email:[email protected] Ph:9849139209.

8.

C.

Surender Reddy, S/o.

Late C.

Ramachandra Reddy, Aged about 50 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Tax, O/o.

Vijayawada GST Division, Vijayawada, R/o.

Vijayawada.

Email:[email protected], Ph:9948112245.

9.

B.

Ram Charan Kumar, S/o.

Late B.

Vijay Kumar, Aged about 53 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Tirupati Audit Circle, Tirupati, Vizag Audit Commissionerate, R/o.

Tirupati, Email:[email protected], Ph:9849074470.

10.

K.

Srinivas, S/o.

Late K.

Veeraiah, Aged about 50 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Central Processing Cell, CCO Vizag (on loan Basis), Guntur Commissionerate, R/o.

Guntur, [email protected], Ph:9502198114.

11.

V.

Ramalingam, Aged about 52 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Nandyal-II Range, Kurnool GST Commissionerate, R/o.

Nandyal.

Email:[email protected], Ph:9866017646.

12.

Sambari Shreenivas Mallayya, S/o.

Late S.

Mallayya, Aged about 53 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Prodatur-II CGST Range, Kaddappa CGST Division, Tirupathi Commissionerate, R/o.

Proddature, Email:[email protected], Ph:9441476091.

13.

Pawar Vasanth Rao, S/o.

Late P.

Kaniram, Aged about 51 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Divisional Office, Nellore CGST Division, Nellore, Guntur Commissionerate, Vizag Zone, R/o.

Nellore, Email:[email protected], Ph:8008105176.

OA/450/2021 Page 3 of 6 14.

Gorige Naveen Kumar, S/o.

Late Sri G.

Narsing Rao, Aged about 50 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Nellore Audit Circle, Guntur Audit Commissionerate, R/o.

Nellore, Email:[email protected], Ph:9440041120.

15.

A.

Rajender, S/o.

Komuraiah, Aged about 49 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.Tirpathi Audit Circle, Guntur Audit Commissionerate, R/o.

Tirupati, Email:[email protected]:9866394680.

16.

Dhanwada Srinivas, S/o.

Seshanna, Aged about 49 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Nidadavole Range, Ramnagar, Nidadavole, Ellure Division, Guntur Commissionerate, R/o.

Nidadavole, Email:[email protected], Ph:9849666484.

17.

C.C.

Subramanyam, S/o.CY.N.Sastry, Aged about 52 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Suryabagh CGST Range, 28-14-10,2nd floor, Suryabagh, Visakhapatnam-20,Visakhapatnam.

Email:[email protected]:9849262868.

18.

N.

Bhanumurthy, S/o.

Satyanarayana, Aged about 50 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, O/o.

Jaggaiahpet Rane, Amaravathi Division, Jaggaihpet – 521 175, R/o.

Jaggaihpet, Email:[email protected], Ph:9848814815.

19.

P.Seshu Kumar, S/o.

P.

Sundara Ramaiah, Aged about 51 years, Group B, Occ: Superintendent of Central Tax, VPT CGST Range, O/o.

Visakhapatnam Central GST Division, R/o.

Visakhapatnam, Email:[email protected], Ph:9989646874. ...Applicants (By Advocate: Sri M.V.

Krishna Mohan) Vs.

OA/450/2021 Page 4 of 6 1.

The Union of India rep. by its Secretary, Ministry of Finance, North Block, New Delhi – 110 001.

The Chairman, CBIT, North Block, New Delhi – 110 001.

The Chief Commissioner of Central Tax, Central Tax Bhavan, 1st floor, Opp.

L.B.

Stadium, L.B.

Stadium Road, Basheerbagh, Hyderabad, Telangana – 500 004.

The Chief Commissioner, Central GST & Customs, Visakhapatnam Zone, Visakhapatnam.

The Principal Commissioner (CCA), Central Tax and Customs, Hyderabad GST Commissionerate, Kendriya Shulk Bhavan, 2nd floor, Opp.

Stadium, LB.

Stadium Road, Basheerbagh, Hyderabad, Telangana – 500 004. ...Respondents (By Advocate: Sri K.

Rajitha, Sr.

CGSC) --- OA/450/2021 Page 5 of 6 ORAL ORDER (As per Hon’ble Mr.

Member) Through Video Conferencing: Heard Sri M.V.

Krishna Mohan, learned counsel for the applicants and Smt K.

Rajitha, learned Senior Central Government Standing Counsel for the respondents.

The applicants have been working as Superintendents on Adhoc basis since 2018. ince 2018.

He was transferred from Hyderabad Zone to Vishakapatnam in the year of 2019.

As per the Inter Zonal Transfer Policy 2020, tenure of 660 days in two years has to be completed and then only an officer can be transferred back to Hyderabad.

The cut-off date is also suggested in the said policy i.e.

30th June of every year.

The applicants’ case is that they are just short of a few days but, they were not considered at all by the respondents for transferring them back to Hyderabad.

Now, they have to wait for another year to be transferred back.

The applicants have also stated that few persons at Sl.19 to 25 have been considered by the respondents even though they too are short of some days in 660 days period required as per the policy.

Thus, they prayed that their case should be considered for transferring back to Hyderabad.

Smt.

Rajitha, learned Senior Central Government Standing Counsel for the respondents put appearance and filed reply.

It is submitted OA/450/2021 Page 6 of 6 in the reply that they have strictly adhered to the Inter Zonal transfer policy.

The persons, who are at Sl.No.19 to 25, have completed their 660 days as on 30th June of the year of consideration.

Be that as it may, the applicants’ concern is that they should be transferred back to Hyderabad.

Else, they have to wait for another year to come back.

After hearing learned counsel for the parties at length, we are of this view that the applicants may make a detailed representation immediately on completion of their 660 days as per the policy and respondents, while making parity between Vizag and Hyderabad zones, may consider and transfer the applicants back to Hyderabad as a one time measure.

This shall not be cited as a precedent for others.

It is observed by the Bench that there may be many persons like the applicants at Hyderabad zone.

In view of the above, we hereby dispose of this Original Application at the admission stage itself.

No order as to costs. to costs. (TARUN SHRIDHAR) (ASHISH KALIA) ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER /al/