NUKALA RAMACHANDRA RAO (M) , vs M/O DEFENCE (M) ,

1 CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : HYDERABAD BENCH ATHYDERABAD C.P./021/124/2017 in O.A./020/350/2017 Date of Order : 12-04-2018 Between : 1.

Nukala Ramachandra Rao, S/o.Nageswara Rao (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.82464, R/o.

D.No.29-8-17/12, Hari Plaza, Lalitha Colony, Dabagardens, Visakhapatnam-530 020.

2.

Nekkanti Raja Rao, S/o.Subba Rao (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81282, R/o.

D.No.15-86, Virat Nagar, R.R.VPuram, Visakhapatnam – 530 029.

3.

Battula Venkateswara Rao, S/o.B.

Raja Rao (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.82729, R/o.

D.No.4-40/2/20, Flat No.504, Krishnas Appartment, RRV.Puram,Visakhapatnam – 530 029.

4.

Ithi Sanyasi Rao, S/o.

I .Prakasha Rao (Late), Aged about 65 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.81583, R/o.

D.No.58-14-14/20, Atul residency, Vuda Layout, Marripalem, Visakhapatnam-530 018.

5.

Darru Tata, S/o.Suryanarayana (Late), Aged about 67 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.82057, R/o.

D.No.15-98, Virat Nagar, RRV Puram, Visakhapatnam-530 029.

6.

Nagamalla Venkata Ramana, S/o.Satya Rao (Late), Aged about 66 years, Retd.

Chargeman, Cin No.83611, R/o.

D.No.20-211/5/20, Sukanya Nagar, 2 Kothapalem, Visakhapatnam-530 027.

7.

Rasananda Sahoo, S/o.Surendra Sahoo (Late), Aged about 61 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81486, R/o.

D.No.48-1-421/422, Santhi Nilayam T-I, NAD Kotha Road, Visakhapatnam - 530 009.

8.

Surikuchi Venkatachala Veerabhadra Rao, S/o.

Somayajulu (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81941, R/o.

Flat No.S-2, Sri Satya Sai Residency, Lakshmi Narasimha Nagar, RRV Puram, Visakhapatnam-530 029.

9.

Kodamalla Tivitha Chary, S/o.Kanakaratnam (Late), Aged about 64 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81388, R/o.

D.No.9-4-302, Jogavanipalem, Gajuwaka, Visakhapatnam-530 026.

10.

Munduru Kasipathi, S/o.MS Achary (Late), Aged about 67 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.82730, R/o.

D.No.2-5/2, Santhosh Nagar, Yellapavani Palem, Visakhapatnam-530 027.

11.

Desapogu Devadas, S/o. adas, S/o.Devadanam (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.83213, R/o.

D.No.39-33-105/3, Madhavadara, VUDA Colony, Visakhapatnam-530 018.

12.YallaKanakalingeswara Rao, S/o.Rudra Rao (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.83146, R/o.

D.No.38-35-39, Rampratap Nagar, Marripalem, Visakhapatnam-530 018.

13.Mavulati Naga Raju, S/o.Rama Raju (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81345, R/o.

D.No.39-33-105/3, Madhavadhara VUDA Colony, 3 Visakhapatnam-530 018.

14.

Kuppili Janardana Rao, S/o.Neelamani Bhushana Rao (Late), Aged about 66 years Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.83656, R/o.

D.No.5-157/3, Santhivanipalem, Krishnaraya Puram, Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam-530 047.

15.

Musinana VaraPrasada Rao, S/o.Chandra Rao (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81498, R/o.

D.No.MIG-20, Simhapuri, Layout, Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam – 530 048.

16.

Kola Hari Chandra Rao, S/o.Arranna (Late), Aged about 67 years, Retd.

Chargeman-II, Cin No.83171, R/o.

D.No.22-24-7, Kanchara Veedhi, Janapareddy varidoddi, Changalrao Peta, Visakhapatnam-530 001.

17.

Malay Kumar Guha, S/o.Amal Chandra Guha, Aged about 61 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81326, R/o.

D.No.38-39-81/7, Bapujinagar, Visakhapatnam-530 007.

18.

Shaik Mahammed Moulali, S/o.Khadar Basha (Late), Aged about 64 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.81948, R/o.

D.No.38-39-86-3/7, Bapuji Nagar, Visakhapatnam- 530 007.

19.

Gullipalli Ananda Rao, S/o.Manikyam (Late), Aged about 71 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.81413, R/o.

D.No.34-13-36,Rossillian Street, Gnanapuram, Visakhapatnam-530 004.

20.

Anipedi Satya Kumar, S/o.A.S.

Ramachandra Murthy, (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

TA, Cin No.81249, R/o.

D.No.39-16-53/6, Madhavadhara, Visakhapatnam-530 007.

4 21.

Kamuju Ammi Rao, S/o.Satyam (Late), Aged about 68 years, Retd.

Chargeman, Cin No.81225, R/o.

D.No.50-79-14,Ganesh Nagar, Seethamma Peta, Visakhapatnam-530 016.

22.

Kosuru Naga Raju, S/o.KVN Achari (Late), Aged about 64 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No. n, Cin No.81349, R/o.

D.No.38-19-44/2A, Jyothinagar, Marripalem, Visakhapatnam-530 018.

23.

Duppati Daniel, S/o.DA Phillip (Late), Aged about 67 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81203, R/o.

D.No.49-35-21/A, Pioneer Residency, NGGOs Colony, Akkayya Palem, Visakhapatnam-530 016.

24.

Vankara Raju, S/o.

Gurumurthy (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81269, R/o.

D.No.50-50-34, TPT Colony, BS Layout, Visakhapatnam-530 013.

25.

Dusi Gopala Rao, S/o.Satyanarayana (Late), Aged about 66 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81155, R/o.

D.No.44-15-26, Tadichetla palem, Visakhapatnam-530 016.

26.

Pidugu Rama Jagga Rao, S/o.Appa Rao (Late), Aged about 65 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.82056, R/o.

D.No.37-6-10, Satyanagar, Manchukonda Gardens, Visakhapatnam-530 007.

27.

VarriVenkuNaidu, S/o.Nookanna (Late), Aged about 69 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.81523, R/o.

D.No.19-27/1, Chandra Nagar,, Visakhapatnam-530 027.

28.

Duddu Ramu Naidu, 5 S/o.Sanyasi Naidu (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.82721, R/o.

D.No.15-117, Viratnagar, RRV Puram, , Visakhapatnam-530 029.

29.

Penuganti Ramu Naidu, S/oYellamNaidu (Late), Aged about 64 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.83136, R/o.

D.No.45-50-9, Raj Enclave, Abidnagar, Visakhapatnam-530 016.

30.

Rokkala Raja Rao, S/o.Dhanumu (Late), Aged about 64 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.83167, R/o.

D.No.31-49-32, Pakeertakya, SC Colony, VadlapudiPost, Kurmanipalem, Visakhapatnam-530 049.

31.

Tammisetty Rama Rao, S/o.Satyanarayana Murthy (Late), Aged about 66 years, Retd.

Chargeman, Cin No.84156, R/o.

D.No.7-197, Varalakshmi Nagar, Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam-530 047.

32.

Nalla Rama Rao, S/o.Dalayya (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.84290, R/o.

D.No.38-31-1/7, Green Gardens, Marripalem,Visakhapatnam-530 018.

33.

Pentakota Venkata Rao, S/o.Venkata Ramana (Late), Aged about 65 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.84197, R/o.

D.No.33-20-98, Visakhapatnam-530 004.

34.

Animeshkanti Biswangri, S/o. ngri, S/o.Rebati Raman Biswangri (Late), Aged about 69 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81062, R/o.

D.No.43-11-58, Sai Sadan Appartments, Subbalakshmi Nagar, Visakhapatnam-530 016.

35.

Dakarapu Syam Sundara Rao, S/o.Satyanarayana (Late), Aged about 62 years, 6 Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.82563, R/o.

D.No.HIG 25, Midhilapur VUDA Colony, Madhurawada, Visakhapatnam-530 041.

36.

Bachela AbbaiVarma, S/o.Latchayya (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81096, R/o.

D.No.10-23, Sri Sai Madhava Nagar, Sector-I, Vepagunta Visakhapatnam-530 047.

37.

Kannedi Veeraswamy, S/o.Venkanna (Late), Aged about 65 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.82694, R/o.

D.No.55-31-46/2/1, Housing Board Colony, Seethammadhara, Visakhapatnam-530 022.

38.

Nethala Yesuratnam, S/o.Novahu (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.83839, R/o.

D.No.6-48, Prasanthi Nagar, Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam-530 047.

39.

Rudraraju Krishnamurthy Raju, S/o.Venkata Raju (Late), Aged about 67 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.82972, R/o.

D.No.E-5, Panchavati Township, Akkireddypalem, BHPV Post, Visakhapatnam-530 012.

40.

Vazhajil Unni Ravi, S/o.P.N.

Kumaran (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81031, R/o.

Punnothankathu House, Anchiry, ThodupuzhaiDukki, Kerala – 685585.

41.

Nakka Nageswara Rao, S/o.Surya Rao (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81461, R/o.Flat .No.102, Varalakshmi Residency, Balaji Gardens RRV Puram, Visakhapatnam-530 029.

42.

VampoluAdinarayana, S/o.Satyanarayana (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.83129, R/o.

D.No.19-242, Sri Sai Madhavanagar, 7 Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam-530 047.

43.

Maniyezhathu Kochumakker Shajahan, S/o.Maniyezhathu Kochumakker (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81494, R/o.

Maniyezhathu House, VeyalarPost, Cherthala Alleppy, Kerala - 688536.

44.

Rongali Sanyasi Naidu, S/o.Kollari (Late), Aged about 65 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.82051, R/o.

D.No.6-624/5, Sai Nagar Colony, Simhachalam, Visakhapatnam - 530028.

45.

30028.

Surusetty Trinadha Rao, S/o.Appala Naidu (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.82971, R/o.

D.No.8-56-1, Varalakshmi Nagar, Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam-530 047.

46.

Kodati Durga Prasad, S/o.Venugopala Rao (Late), Aged about 61 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.82071, R/o.

D.No.10-85/15, Vijaya Enclave, Gayatrinagar, PM Palem, Visakhapatnam-530 041.

47.

Maradepudi Demudu, S/o.Sree Ramulu (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.83138, R/o.

D.No.14-381, Lakshmi Nagar, Gopalapatnam,Visakhapatnam-530 027.

48.

Dasari Sudhakar, S/o.Sivaramayya (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.81522, R/o.

D.No.26-23-2, Chaitanya Nagar, Old Gajuwaka, Visakhapatnam-530 026.

49.

Movva Siva Nageswara Rao, S/o.Pitchaiah (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81520, R/o.

D.No.

26-23-5-1/3,Chaitanya Nagar, Old Gajuwaka, Visakhapatnam-530 026.

50.

VobbilisettyMahendra, 8 S/o.VSN Murthy (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81524, R/o.

D.No.49-26-61, Madhura Nagar, Visakhapatnam-530 016.

51.

Prasada Vijaya Saradhi, S/o.Pentayya (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81531, R/o.

D.No.4-155/4, Ajantha Park, RRV Puram, Visakhapatnam-530 029.

52.

Puthan Purayil Balan, S/o.Panniot Kelan (Late), Aged about 62 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.81262, R/o.

D.No.282D, Vrinda Vanam, Chattukapara Post, Kodali, Kannanoor, Kerala - 670592.

53.

Dakarapu Vivekananda Swamy, S/o.Vayunandana Rao (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.TA, Cin No.84320, R/o.

D.No.19-170 Sector-II, Sri Sai Madhava Nagar, Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam-530 047.

54.

Kattoju Appalachari, S/o.Chandrayya (Late), Aged about 65 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.83594, R/o.

D.No.19-135, Sri Sai Madhava Nagar, Sector-II Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam-530 047.

55.

Palisetti Manohar, S/o.Sri Rama Murthy (Late), Aged about 61 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.84951, R/o.

19-190, Sri Sai Madhava Nagar, Sector-II Vepagunta, Visakhapatnam-530 047.

56.

Kollabathula Peddi Raju, S/o.

Raju, S/o.Mahankali (Late), Aged about 67 years, Retd.

Asst.

Foreman, Cin No.81362, R/o.

D.No.55-6-41, Ambedkar Colony, Isakathota, Visakhapatnam-530 022.

57.

Krishna Chandra Bhanja, 9 S/o.Ananda Bhanja (Late), Aged about 61 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.84245, R/o.

Flat.No.45&46, Sri Sai Lakshmi Haritha Residency, Jyothinagar, Marripalem, Visakhapatnam-530 018.

58.

Katumuri Appa Rao, S/o.Appala Swamy (Late), Aged about 65 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.82917, R/o.

D.No.36-94-279/7,Arundathi Nagar, Visakhapatnam -530 008.

59.

Balla Narasinga Rao, S/o.Ramana (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Chargeman-I, Cin No.81529, R/o.

Flat.No.305, Sai Leela Residency, KRM Colony, Seethamma Dhara, Visakhapatnam-530 013.

60.

Barla Sampath Kumar, S/o.Govinda Rao (Late), Aged about 63 years, Retd.

Foreman, Cin No.83155, R/o.

D.No.6-10-32, Peethala VeedhiDown, Chinna Waltair,Visakhapatnam-530 017. ....Applicants AND 1.

Shri Sanjay Mitra I.A.S., Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block, New Delhi.

Admiral Sunil Lanba, Chief of Naval Staff, Integrated Headquarters of Ministry of Defence (Navy), New Delhi.

Vice Admiral Karambir Singh, Flag Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Headquarters, Eastern Naval Command, Visakhapatnam.

Rear Admiral Narayan Prasad, Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, Visakhapatnam. ...Respondents Counsel for the Applicant : Dr.P.B.

Vijay Kumar Counsel for the Respondents : Mr.M.

Brahma Reddy 10 CORAM : THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE R.KANTHA RAO, JUDICIAL MEMBER THE HON’BLE MRS.

MINNIE MATHEW, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER (Oral order per Hon’ble Mr.Justice R.Kantha Rao, Judicial Member ) --- Dr.

P.

B.

Vijay Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the applicants submits that the order passed in OA has been complied with by disposing of the applicants representation by a reasoned and speaking order.

Contempt Petition is therefore closed.

However,the petitioners counsel wants to challenge the order passed by the Respondents.

He can do so by filing a fresh O.A.

3. sh O.A.

No order as to costs. (MINNIE MATHEW) (R.KANTHA RAO) ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER Dated : 12th April, 2018.

Dictated in Open Court. vl